Sacrifice (2009)

Before the show was broadcast live, a match aired on TNA's web site and for free on television, which pitted Amazing Red against Kiyoshi. Red won the match by pinfall after performing a standing shooting star press.[7]

Jay Lethal, competitor in the Six-Man Tag Team match to open the show

The first match on the show was a Six-Man Tag Team match between the team of Eric Young and Lethal Consequences (Jay Lethal and Consequences Creed) against The Motor City Machine Guns (Chris Sabin and Alex Shelley) and Sheik Abdul Bashir. A the end of the match, Lethal was able to get the win for his team by pinning Bashir with a sunset flip.[7]

The next match was the Monster's Ball match between Taylor Wilde and Daffney (with Abyss in her corner). Both women exchanged weapons shots before Wilde was able to get a pinfall victory over Daffney after using a fireman's carry takeover to throw Daffney onto a trash can. Following the match, Abyss' storyline therapist, Dr. Stevie, came down to the ring with a bag filled with thumbtacks and demanded Abyss to throw Wilde onto the contents of the bag that were spilled onto the mat. After some influence from Lauren, an interviewer for TNA with personal ties to both Wilde and Abyss, he turned on Stevie by chokeslamming him onto the thumbtacks.[7]

Daniels challenged Suicide for the TNA X Division Championship after he saved Suicide from an attack a week prior on Impact! by the Motor City Machineguns. During their match, the Motor City Machineguns, who were determined to reveal the identity of Suicide, attacked him before fleeing the ring. Daniels did not realize the attack had occurred and pinned his opponent. Once he saw a replay, he refused to accept the title under the circumstances. He requested the match continue, adding five minutes, which expired, leading to Suicide retaining the title.[7]

Following was a second title match for the TNA Women's Knockout Championship, which pitted Angelina Love, the champion, against Awesome Kong. During the match, Love repeatedly ran from Kong before being blocked by Kong's manager, Raisha Saeed. Kong took the opportunity beat down on her opponent before the referee was distracted. Love then grabbed a can of hair spray and sprayed it into Kong's eyes and capitalized on her opponent's compromised state by executing a roll up-style cover to get the pinfall victory. Following the match, Kong recovered from the attack and performed her signature drop, the Implant Buster, driving Love's face into the mat, before the leaving the ring.[7]

Next was the match between Samoa Joe and Kevin Nash. Joe won the match by applying a choke with a half nelson hold. After the victory, he continued to beat on Nash with elbow strikes before several officials came to the ring to break them up.[8]

The finals for the "Team 3D Invitational Tag Team Tournament" was the first of the main event matches, and Beer Money, Inc. was wrestling against The British Invasion (Brutus Magnus and Doug Williams). Storm performed a headscissors takedown from the top rope on Williams followed by a top rope body press by Roode to his downed opponent. Roode pinned Williams to with the match for Beer Money, Inc. after the latter was hit in the face with one of the briefcases that The British Invasion had recently commandeered.[8]

A.J. Styles, TNA Legends Champion

Following this match was the "I Quit" match for the TNA Legends Championship between A.J. Styles and Booker T with his wife, Sharmell, in his corner. At the beginning of the match, Booker took Styles to the outside of the ring, dropping him throat-first onto the guardrail; every time the referee gave him the microphone, a way for the wrestler to say, "I quit", Styles would not speak. Styles reversed the momentum with a backflip kick, called the Pelé Kick, to Booker's face. For the finish to the match, Styles locked in an armbar on Booker whilst in mid-air; Booker's reluctant ally in the Main Event Mafia, Jenna Morasca, came to the ring and threw a towel in the ring, signifying Booker's concession.[8]

The TNA World Heavyweight Championship match between defending champion Mick Foley, Kurt Angle, Jeff Jarrett, and Sting was next. The match quickly turned into a brawl on the outside of the ring and the entrance ramp. During the match, Foley decided to take a rest and started doing commentary while all three of his opponents continued to wrestle. Fellow members of the Main Event Mafia, Angle and Sting, double teamed Jarrett before a communications breakdown, leading to the two fighting each other. After Sting was taken down, Angle turned his attention to Foley at the announcers table, diving onto him. Foley returned to the ring and stuffed a dirty old sock into the mouths of both Sting and Jarrett, attempting a dual submission. The match ended when Jarrett dropped Angle from the second turnbuckle with his finishing maneuver, the Stroke, onto a chair. Meanwhile, Sting sneaked into the ring and pinned Angle, winning the match. As a result of the pre-match stipulation, Sting became the leader of the Main Event Mafia.[8]

The show was given positive feedback from critics. Dave Meltzer, writer of the professional wrestling periodical, The Wrestling Observer Newsletter, said multiple times in his pay-per-view report for the show that it, "overachieved", and he gave special attention to the "Team 3D Invitational Tag Team Tournament" finals and the "I quit" match. The only form of criticism he gave the show were some of the illogical booking tactics made by the company.[7] The Pro Wrestling Torch reporter, James Caldwell, gave the show a generally good review, but also criticized the show in a number of spots, specifically the "I quit" match: "Best match of the PPV until the finish with Sharmell-Jenna continuing their feud on PPV TV. Keep it on free TV (if TNA is so adamant about continuing this), but don't put that dumb storyline on pay TV. As usual, TNA tries to find a way out of a stipulation. Sucks to rant on that, because the match was awesome and one of Booker's best performances in years."[8]

A common theme amongst the criticism was the "lack of common sense", as wrestling journalist, Ben Miller, put it.[9] He made particular mention to the World title match, by saying, "...there was no reason for Jarrett, Angle or Foley to attempt to beat Sting. You can win a championship, control of the company, leadership of a powerful faction or... what? If you end Sting’s career do you become six-time WCW World Heavyweight Champion. There is, of course, the argument that by pinning Sting you eliminate a potential rival. I don’t think the crowd bought that argument. The heat was spotty during the match and the lack of a sensible reason for attacking Sting appeared to be a big part of it. TNA Sacrifice 2009 felt flat, but it shouldn’t have. Most everyone worked hard, some angles paid off and some angles left fans intrigued. Those three ingredients usually make for a good show. Instead, one-third of the matches had conceptual problems...".[9]