Lay judges in Taiwan

In her second inaugural address, President Tsai Ing-wen discussed implementing a lay judge system.[2] Subsequently, the preparatory committee for the second National Conference on Judicial Reform was convened in November 2016,[3] following the first conference in July 1999,[4][5] which led to amendments of the Code of Criminal Procedure in February 2003.[6][7]

The 2016–2017 conference considered a number of proposals, including decriminalizing defamation to protect freedom of speech,[8] extending protections offered to judicial victims,[9] independent evaluation of judicial performance,[10] and more amendments to the Code of Criminal Procedure and Implementation Rules of the Code of Criminal Procedure, drafts of which were approved in July 2019.[11]

Throughout the tenure of the second National Conference on Judicial Reform, judicial reform advocacy organizations continued backing a transition to the jury system.[12][13] Specific concerns with the lay judge system included potential political and monetary influence via the career judges sharing the bench,[14][15] or that the opinions of the professional judges would influence decisions of their lay counterparts.[16]

Bills regarding a lay judge system proposed by the Judicial Yuan were not voted upon in the previous legislative session, leading the Executive Yuan to propose a similar bill for discussion in March 2020.[17][18] The Judicial Yuan also suggested another draft act for citizen participation in criminal trial procedures,[19] stating that the lay judge system allowed citizens to be active in deciding verdicts and sentences, while eliminating hung juries.[20] Cross-caucus negotiations took place throughout July,[21] necessitating an extraordinary session of the Legislative Yuan to be convened.[22][23] The 113 articles of the Citizen Judges Act passed a third legislative reading on 22 July 2020.[24] Upon its passage, the Citizen Judges Act was described as "a major landmark" for judicial reform by Judicial Yuan president Hsu Tzong-li, and by Tsai Ing-wen as "a new era of people's participation in the...judiciary."[25] The Citizen Judges Act took effect on 1 January 2023.[26] In the act, lay judges are described as national judges.[27] At the district court level, six lay judges would review premeditated crimes leading to death, or crimes requiring imprisonment of ten years or more, alongside three career judges.[27][26] Six of the nine judges, including one career judge, must concur for a guilty verdict.[26] The same majority must concur for a death penalty to be decided.[26] Lay judges are barred from hearing court cases involving minors or drug charges.[26] To serve as a lay judge, one must be a citizen of the Republic of China, be at least 23 years old, have completed a high school education or equivalent, and have lived within the jurisdiction of the district court for four months.[26] Those with a criminal record cannot serve as a lay judge.[26] Under the Citizen Judges Act, exemptions from service may be granted to educators, students, those above 70 years of age, people with health conditions that could be exacerbated by participation in legal proceedings, or those with difficulty setting aside home and work duties.[26]