Hercules (1983 film)

• Giovanni Cianfriglia
• Mindi Miller

The film received largely negative reviews from critics. Lawrence Van Gelder of The New York Times believed that — as in The Incredible Hulk — Ferrigno "is once again called upon mainly to flex his inflated muscles and lend himself to the sometimes less than special effects".[24] According to Chris Walters from Austin American-Statesman, the film relies too heavily on "muscle stunts and old-fashioned optical effects". The critic also thought that Ferrigno's "total lack of acting ability" is "more or less compensated for by a really expressive set of pectoral muscles".[25] The Boston Globe's Jay Carr wrote that the film "modeled itself after Clash of the Titans", which separated it from many Star Wars rip-offs of its time.[26] Carr noted that Ferrigno's Hercules is not a "dumb beefcake" but also remarked that the actor's "copiously muscled body looks unreal".[26] Writing for The Pittsburgh Press, Ed Blank shared similar sentiments: he called the film a "chintzy rerun of Clash of the Titans", and noticed that Ferrigno "flexes his bulging pectorals more than 100 times onscreen".[27] Andrew Adler from The Courier-Journal believed that the film's special effects "would have looked silly in a Buck Rogers serial of the 1930s".[8] Adler's critique towards Lou Ferrigno was mixed — he thought that Ferrigno's "interpretation rarely goes beyond flexing his pectorals, but at least he looks earnest".[8]

Marylynn Uricchio, a film critic for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, criticized the narration and the dialogue but applauded the leading actor. She wrote: "Ferrigno's only requirement is to arrange his face in the appropriate expression, and this he does well".[28] On the other hand, Henry Edgar from Daily Press called Ferrigno's leading role "a major flaw", yet labelled the film as "a lavish spectacle", "packed with action and color in epic proportions". Of Ferrigno he said that "his massive body can't compensate for the lack of expertise".[29]

Ben Steelman of Star-News lambasted the film for its "tacky" special effects, including the "metallic robot creatures, which make noises like popular video games".[30] He noted that "as beefcake, Ferrigno makes Arnold Schwarzenegger look like a 90-pound weakling, and he flexes his pectorals frequently. Obviously, he is supposed to appeal to the mommies in the audience".[30] Kansas City critic Robert C. Trussell gave the film one star, calling it even less satisfying than "low-budget Italian-made mythological epics of two decades ago". He pointed that Ferrigno mostly just "grunts, puffs, sweats and flexes in the title role".[20] In his review for the Tallahassee Democrat Steve Watkins observed that "Ferrigno is a bodybuilder extraordinaire; he's a Hulk, he's even a Hercules, but he's no actor".[31]

On Rotten Tomatoes, the film has a 25% rating based on 8 reviews, with an average rating of 2.2/10.[32] However, over the years Hercules has become a cult movie.[33][34][35]

Leonard Maltin briefly reviewed Hercules in his 2015 film guide. He called the movie "silly" and "special-effects-laden", but aimed praise towards Lou Ferrigno, mentioning that "the ex-Incredible Hulk is undeniably well cast".[36] In the official write-up for the Smithee Awards website, Bryan Cassidy noted that the film "is avant-garde to the point of being particularly ludicrous". He said that "if anyone's going to play Hercules, Lou Ferrigno pops right to mind", but also stated that the actor "can't really emote well".[37] AllMovie's critic Eleanor Mannikka panned the film for its "off-color" stage sets and low-budget execution, summarizing it as a "difficult challenge to conquer".[38]

In 2012, Andy Brack of Charleston City Paper opined that "Kevin Sorbo, Arnold Schwarzenegger, and Steve Reeves' takes on the titular Grecian beefcake can't touch Ferrigno's". The critic praised the film for its "brawn, bunk effects, and dialogue worthy of a good round of alcohol-induced Mystery Science Theater 3000-style riffing".[39] Gary Allen Smith remarks in his book, Epic Films, that "the production design [of the film] is imaginative, considering the limitations of the budget, but the visuals are often marred by poor quality of the special effects". The author also praises the main star's physical strength and aesthetics: "At 6'5" and 262 pounds, Lou Ferrigno is a massive and thoroughly convincing Hercules".[7] Decider's Meghan O'Keefe named Ferrigno the tenth "hottest onscreen Hercules", calling him "well-greased".[40]