Battle of Brookvale
The Battle of Brookvale was the unofficial name given to the Round 25, 2011 National Rugby League (NRL) match between the Manly Warringah Sea Eagles and Melbourne Storm, played at Brookvale Oval on 26 August 2011.
| Battle of Brookvale | |||||||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 Cover of Big League match programme | |||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||
| |||||||||||||
| Date | 26 August 2011 | ||||||||||||
| Stadium | Brookvale Oval | ||||||||||||
| Location | Brookvale, New South Wales | ||||||||||||
| Referees | Shayne Hayne, Gavin Badger | ||||||||||||
| Attendance | 20,414 | ||||||||||||
| Broadcast partners | |||||||||||||
| Broadcasters | |||||||||||||
| Commentators | |||||||||||||
A number of incidents in the first half led to some fights breaking out all over the ground, eventually turning into a five-minute brawl involving all players on the ground. Following the brawl, Manly went on to win the match 18–4, on its way to finishing second on the premiership ladder.
Several players faced charges at the NRL Judiciary with several suspensions and fines being handed out.
Background
Between 2000 - 2010, the Manly Warringah Sea Eagles and the Melbourne Storm engaged in a rivalry which included several close matches, some upset victories, and a Grand Final victory to each side. Since 2006, ten of fourteen Grand Finals have featured either one or both clubs, and, in the five of six seasons between 2007 and 2012, one of these teams won the premiership, though the Storm's 2007 and 2009 titles (the former of which was won by defeating Manly in the Grand Final) were later stripped from the club as a result of salary cap breaches exposed by the NRL in 2010.[1]
The height of this rivalry came with the two clubs' meetings in the 2007 and 2008 NRL Grand Finals. Melbourne defeated Manly 34–8 to win the 2007 title, whilst Manly reversed the result and won by a record 40–0 scoreline in 2008. They have also featured in three other finals matches, with Melbourne winning all three by the scoreline of 40–12 in the 2009 qualifying final, the 2012 preliminary final and the 2021 first qualifying final.
This was to be the first match attended by then NRL chief executive officer David Gallop of either side since suspending Brett Stewart from the first four weeks of the 2009 season for a sexual assault charge for which he would later be exonerated, and since stripping the Storm of two premiership titles and three minor premiership titles for salary cap breaches; extra security was hired for his presence at the game.[2]
In the preview for the match, the official programme Big League noted that the feud between the teams was "set to reignite," but that there was a "mutual respect between the two clubs".[3] Melbourne entered the match on top of the NRL ladder, on a 12-match winning streak, while Manly were in second position having won their three previous matches.
During the match
Before the brawl
Kieran Foran scored the first try of the match for the Sea Eagles early in the first half, after Billy Slater misjudged a ball which had bounced in the Sea Eagles' in-goal area.[4]
In the 23rd minute of the match, Manly winger David Williams suffered a neck injury, which resulted in play being suspended whilst he was carried off the stretcher. In stark contrast to what would come later in the game, Billy Slater who had tackled Williams (Williams had hit Slater's chest with the top of his head which caused the injury), realising there was a neck injury, cradled Williams and wouldn't let him move or his Manly team mates move him until the medical staff arrived.[4][5]
The brawl
Shortly after the Williams injury, Melbourne interchange forward Ryan Hinchcliffe conceded a penalty when he struck Manly's Darcy Lussick close to the Sea Eagles' line.[6] This resulted in a brawl between the two players, following which Adam Blair and Glenn Stewart were sin-binned for joining in.
On their way to the dressing rooms, a major brawl erupted between Blair and Stewart, which involved players and officials from both sides; the two subsequently had their sin-bin punishments upgraded to a send off, meaning they would take no further part in the match.[7]
Apart from the main culprits, many other players, including Brett Stewart, also joined in the brawl, with Stewart claiming that he was acting in self-defence of his older brother. Officials and trainers from both clubs also joined in the brawl.[8]
After the brawl
Manly captain Jamie Lyon converted a penalty goal from the Hinchcliffe penalty from right in front, extending the Sea Eagles' lead to 8–0. The Sea Eagles would eventually win 18–4 with a late Billy Slater try preventing the Storm from being held scoreless for the first time since the 2008 NRL Grand Final.[4]
Teams
Melbourne were missing regular halfback Cooper Cronk due to a foot injury, with Jesse Bromwich also missing the match after being named in the original squad.[3]
| Manly Warringah Sea Eagles | Position | Melbourne Storm | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Name | Number | Number | Name | |
| Brett Stewart | 1 | Fullback | 1 | Billy Slater |
| Michael Robertson | 2 | Wing | 2 | Matthew Duffie |
| Jamie Lyon (c) | 3 | Centre | 3 | Dane Nielsen |
| Steve Matai | 4 | Centre | 4 | Beau Champion |
| David Williams | 5 | Wing | 5 | Anthony Quinn |
| Kieran Foran | 6 | Five eighth | 6 | Rory Kostjasyn |
| Daly Cherry-Evans | 7 | Half back | 7 | Gareth Widdop |
| Joe Galuvao | 12 | Prop forward | 8 | Bryan Norrie |
| Matt Ballin | 9 | Hooker | 9 | Cameron Smith (c) |
| Brent Kite | 10 | Prop forward | 17 | Jaiman Lowe |
| Anthony Watmough | 11 | Second row | 11 | Adam Blair |
| Shane Rodney | 16 | Second row | 16 | Todd Lowrie |
| Glenn Stewart | 13 | Lock forward | 13 | Kevin Proctor |
| George Rose | 8 | Interchange | 12 | Sika Manu |
| Darcy Lussick | 14 | Interchange | 14 | Ryan Hinchcliffe |
| Jamie Buhrer | 15 | Interchange | 15 | Sisa Waqa |
| Tony Williams | 17 | Interchange | 16 | Adam Woolnough |
| Des Hasler | Coach | Craig Bellamy | ||
| RLP[3] | ||||
Match details
Manly Warringah Sea Eagles  |
18 – 4 |  Melbourne Storm |
|---|---|---|
| Tries: 3 T Williams  36', 57'Foran 5'Goals: 3 Lyon  6', pen 27', 37' (3/4)Sin bin: G Stewart  Sent off: G Stewart  27' |
1st: 14–0 2nd: 4–4 Report |
Tries: 1 Slater 80'Goals: 0 Widdop (0/1) Sin bin: Blair Sent off: Blair 27' |
Brookvale Oval, Sydney Attendance: 20,414 Referees: Shayne Hayne, Gavin Badger Touch judges: Ricky McFarlane, Paul Holland |
Judiciary
No fewer than ten players and two officials from both clubs were later charged by the NRL Judiciary for their roles in the brawl, with both Glenn Stewart and Adam Blair referred straight to the judiciary. Additionally, each club was fined $50,000 from the NRL.[9][8][10] For their parts, Stewart and Blair were both banned for three and five matches respectively.[11][12]
The charges and outcomes were as follows:
Manly
| Player | Charge | Grade | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Glenn Stewart | Contrary Conduct – fighting | Referred | Three-match suspension[12] |
| Darcy Lussick | Contrary Conduct | 4 | Three-match suspension (318 demerit points)[13][14] |
| Brett Stewart | Contrary Conduct | 3 | One-match suspension (162 demerit points)[13] |
| Kieran Foran | Contrary Conduct | 2 | One-match suspension (168 demerit points)[13][15] |
| Michael Robertson | Contrary Conduct | 1 | No suspension (62 demerit points)[13] |
Melbourne
| Player | Charge | Grade | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Blair | Contrary Conduct – fighting | Referred | Five-match suspension[11] |
| Striking | 2 | ||
| Sisa Waqa | Detrimental Conduct | 2 | One-match suspension (168 demerit points)[13] |
| Bryan Norrie | Detrimental Conduct | 1 | No suspension (62 demerit points)[13] |
| Jaiman Lowe | Detrimental Conduct | 1 | No suspension (93 demerit points)[13] |
| Sika Manu | Detrimental Conduct | 1 | No suspension (52 demerit points)[13] |
Reaction
Then-NRL CEO David Gallop condemned the actions of both teams, saying:
The sight of so many players from both teams fighting, of people running in and leaving the bench area, was a horrendous look for the game.
Despite the spiteful nature of the match, Melbourne's Billy Slater won universal praise for his actions after the neck injury to Manly winger David Williams.
Aftermath
In the years following this match, matches between the Sea Eagles and Storm played at Brookvale Oval continue to often be called the "Battle of Brookvale", though there have not been any particularly violent matches between the two sides at this venue since.[16] While there is still a healthy rivalry between the two sides in recent years, including another all-in brawl in a match at AAMI Park in Melbourne in 2018,[17] it has not been as strong.
References
- Munro, Ian (23 April 2010). "Melbourne Storm stripped of everything". The Age. Retrieved 23 April 2010.
- Honeysett, Stuart (24 August 2011). "Security for David Gallop at Brookvale". The Australian. Retrieved 11 November 2011.
- Marshall, Matt (25 August 2011). "Title Fight". Big League. Alexandria, New South Wales: News Magazines Pty Ltd. 92 (25): 14–15.
- Sea Eagles rout Storm in fiery clash, ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation), 26 August 2011
- "NRL: Neck injury ends Williams' season". New Zealand Herald. 29 August 2011. Retrieved 11 November 2011.
- Manly Sea Eagles beat Melbourne Storm 18-4 in NRL round 25, The Daily Telegraph, 27 August 2011
- Jackson, Glenn (27 August 2011). "Battle of Brookie set to take toll on big guns' title assault". Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 11 November 2011.
- No less than 12 players and officials from Manly and Melbourne Storm will be scrutinized by the NRL, Fox Sports Australia, 29 August 2011
- Mass charges after Battle of Brookvale Archived November 12, 2013, at the Wayback Machine, Sports News First, 29 August 2011
- Ritchie, Dean (29 August 2011). "Manly Sea Eagles and Melbourne Storm fined $50,000 each and 10 players charged by NRL judiciary after 'Battle of Brookie'". The Daily Telegraph (Sydney). Retrieved 11 November 2011.
- Blair banned for five for Battle of Brookvale Archived November 12, 2013, at the Wayback Machine, Sports News First, 31 August 2011
- Fight night: Stewart, Blair out for season, Sydney Morning Herald, 30 August 2011
- Middleton, David (ed.). 2011 Official Rugby League Annual. Sydney: News Magazines. p. 101.
- Darcy Lussick's brawl gloating draws David Gallop's ire, The Australian, 1 September 2011
- Ban halts Manly's playmaker Kieran Foran from facing Darren Lockyer, The Australian, 31 August 2011
- Proszenko, Adrian (26 October 2019). "'Battle of Brookvale' to headline blockbuster start to NRL season". Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 16 March 2020.
- "Four sin bins, a send-off and time-keeping drama as Manly beat Storm". NRL.com. 19 May 2018. Retrieved 23 August 2020.