Where in Time Is Carmen Sandiego? (video game)

Players start out as a Time Cadet (and throughout the game get promoted to Time Patroller, Time Investigator, Time Inspector, Time Detective, Ace Time Detective, and finally Super Time Sleuth), and need to "track the criminals' movements, figure out where he or she is going next, obtain a warrant for his or her arrest, and send a 'Capture Robot' to arrest the thief".[3] The player finds this hideout by following the "trail throughout the time stream". The player asks people for clues, and every travel clue given at a location gives the player a hint as to the next destination. The player clicks on whichever of the 4 travel options fits the clue, and is then sent there to receive the next clue. They know if they reach the correct location if they see a short animation of a VILE agent upon arrival. The player also gets clues about the culprit's physical appearance and what their likes/hobbies are, which the player then uses to make the warrant. The player is able to arrest the crook if they have the correct warrant and are in the correct location before the time runs out. The player has to capture 80 criminals in order to beat the game.[7]

The game can be played in five different languages: English, French, Spanish, German and Italian.[8]

From the time the game was released (August 1989) up until January 21, 1990, the game had sold "more than 100,000 copies". The game was "the best-selling software game during the 1989 holiday season".[12] After shipping all 95,000 copies of the bundled encyclopedia it ordered in October 1989, Broderbund requested a special print run of 35,000 more copies in December.[13]

Macworld named the Macintosh version of Where in Time Is Carmen Sandiego the Best Adventure Game of 1990, putting it into the Macintosh Game Hall of Fame, and called the graphics and gameplay "top-notch".[11]

Compute! in 1989 stated that Where in Time was the most exciting in the series. It concluded that "besides being one great game [it] has the added value of being an exceptional educational program".[14] Computer Gaming World also favorably reviewed the game, stating that it was "challenging and fun, as well as educational".[15] Entertainment Weekly picked the game as the #13 greatest game available in 1991: "The first-ever video game to come packaged with its own softcover encyclopedia. Playing a 'time sleuth', you travel to various countries in various historical epochs, trying to accumulate enough clues to track down (for instance) the man who stole Paul Revere's horse".[16]

A review by Something Awful gave a mixed response. It found that "the mission of learning historical facts worked but unfortunately came with the fatal flaw of having absolutely no confidence in my answers". The rating system for the site is that the scores for each section range from 0 (the best) to −10 (the worst). The game was given −2 for graphics, −8 for gameplay, −4 for story, −10 for sound and −10 for fun. The overall score was −34 out of a possible worst score of −50.[7] A Newsday review noted its educational nature, saying it is "unlike most other video games which contain fast-paced action". It gave the game a rating of 8 out of 10.[8] Nintendo Power gave the SNES version of the game a score of 3.2/5 in March 1993.[17] A Power Play review for the Genesis version, published in June 1992, gave the game a score of 57 out of 100.[18] Nintendo Power magazine gave the version a score of 3.6 out of 5 in November 1991, and Electronic Gaming Monthly (EGM) gave the version a rating of 58 the same month as well. GamePro (US) gave the NES version a rating of 5 out of 5 in December 1991.[19]

A 1998 allgame review of the Macintosh version of the game by Lisa Karen Savignano commented on the game's sameness to the previous World title, and insinuated that a player's response to one game would determine how they respond to the other. She comments that the animated clip of the robot capturing the criminal "is cute the first couple of times you see it, but quickly grows boring and tiresome to the older set". She also commented on the "realistic sounds" of the deathtraps and the "improbable-sounding names" of the villains. Overall, she gave the game a score of 3/5 stars. This breaks down into: 3 stars for graphics ("static and photorealistic [and] cartoony"), 3.5 stars for sound ("they tell you if you...are on the right track"), 2 stars for enjoyment ("older kids may find it tiresome and continually the same"), 3.5 stars for replay value ("the game always plays differently each time, but your 80th case is always Carmen Sandiego"), and 3 stars for documentation ("a slim manual...explains the basics of the game"). [20] PC Mag wrote that the game "sharpens a student's powers of deductive reasoning".[21]

In 2014, The Av Club described the game as "the closest thing to a good Doctor Who game", arguing that "Where In Time still replicated the sense of adventure, danger, and mystery that gives Doctor Who so much of its life. The rhythms of each mission mirror an episode of Doctor Who almost exactly: The hero turns up unannounced, sticks his nose where it doesn't belong, solves a mystery in the nick of time, and zips away without bothering with cleanup or paperwork. Players travel through time in a Chronoskimmer that functions much the same way as the Doctor's TARDIS, serving as not just a vehicle but also as a mobile lab and headquarters. The Chronoskimmer's scanner is similarly reminiscent of the Doctor's sonic screwdriver, since both are all-purpose gadgets used to quickly pick useful information out of a scene, and both make satisfying electronic chirping noises when used".[22]

Screenshot of England in the year 1212.

The game's locations are China, England, France, Holland, India, Italy, Japan, Mexico, Peru, Russia, Spain, and the USA.

Each location can be visited during four different time periods: 400 to 1300, 1300 to 1700, 1700 to 1900, and 1900 to the present day.

• Where in Time Is Carmen Sandiego? at MobyGames
• Edutainment Odyssey, Episode 1 – Where in Time is Carmen Sandiego?
• Manual of 1991 version