Victorian Architecture Medal
The Victorian Architecture Medal is the highest honour awarded annually by the Victorian Chapter of the Australian Institute of Architects and has been awarded 38 consecutive times since 1987. The Medal was originally known as the ‘Street Architecture Medal’ introduced by the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects (RVIA) in 1926 as an award for the design of a building of exceptional merit.[1] Buildings were judged on their "urban propriety and architectural etiquette; the building had to front a street, road, square or court" and with a requirement of being publicly accessible, thereby excluding residential and private commissions.
The Medal is awarded from the Named Award winners from all direct entry categories and Sustainable Architecture and Colorbond Award for Steel Architecture, and also the winners of the Melbourne Prize or Regional Prize are eligible. The winner of the Victorian Architecture Medal is judged to be the most outstanding project of the year, drawn from all entries and by definition making it a building, place or structure of exceptional merit, and often winning multiple prizes across varying categories. A cast circular bronze medal is awarded to the winner and usually affixed on the winning project in a prominent position.
The medal winner is to have a strong civic and public character — with architectural qualities that contribute to the greater public realm of the city. Two notable exceptions are the awarding of the Medal to John Wardle Architecture for a private residence in 1997 and Wood Marsh for the Yve Apartment building in 2006. Changes to the fundamental concept of 'public architecture' being the basis for the judging of the award occurred after World War II, with the first post war Medal being awarded in 1953 to Roy Grounds House for a residential house and four apartments. This was followed up ten years later with the private and remote Grimwalde House by McGlashan Everist awarded the second Medal in 1963. On five occasions it has been awarded to projects located outside metropolitan Melbourne (2022, 1997, 1987, 1963 and 1940).
To some degree the Melbourne Prize that commenced in 1996 has become the primary award addressing the civic and public realm contribution of architecture, but does not focus solely on the experience of the 'street'.
Street Architecture Medal (1929–1942)
The Royal Victorian Institute of Architect's (RVIA) 'Street Architecture Medal' is considered the predecessor and equivalent of the current Victorian Architecture Medal. It was first awarded in 1929 and consecutively 14 times until 1942. The Street Architecture Award was an idea imported from the Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA) that had started an award with the same name in 1923, an idea which had been around since before World War I. The award was created to encourage design excellence in architecture and increase public interest in the 'street architecture' of London. The first award for best public building in London was made to W. Curtis Green for Wolseley House, 157–160 Piccadilly.[2]
The 'Extracts from the Examining Jury’s Report' of the first Victorian award by chair P.A. Oakley and jury were reported in the Journal of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects in July 1929.[3]"As architects, we feel deeply the proud responsibility enjoyed by members of our profession as sponsors of the city buildings which form possibly the most important visible expression of a city’s individuality and attractions." The jury could recognise any building built within the past five years, with the objectives of the award listed as twofold —"Firstly, that buildings which notably contribute to the civic beauty and architecture of the cities of this State should be publicly singled out and acknowledged, in order that universal appreciation of their good qualities and emulation of their characteristics may be encouraged, and that through this means a widespread sense of civic responsibility may be developed and fostered in the architects and citizens of our State..." and secondly that "...due recognition by his fellow practitioners and fellow citizens may be made of the high achievement of the architect responsible for a building deemed worthy of this award...". It was also noted that a competition was to be held for the design of the bronze plaque to be attached to the winning building, open to RVIA Members and students.
The first medal was presented to Francis House at 107 Collins Street in Melbourne, a narrow fronted five storey office building with a ground level shopfront, designed by architects and cousins Blackett and Forster. William Blackett was the then president of the RVIA in his second term (1928–1930).[4] The building still stands in near original condition. It was built in 1927–1928 for the established pharmacists and chemists, Henry Francis & Co. It was notable for its bronze shopfront details and beige and orange retractable awning, inspired by the shopping streets of Paris and New York, greatly contributing to the characterisation of the area as the 'Paris End' of Collins Street.
In 1936 the president of the RVIA described the purpose of the award was to "encourage excellence of design and public interest in street architecture, the Institute having decided to examine annually buildings completed during the previous three years and to award a medal for a building of exceptional merit". Describing the 1937 medal winning project the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons Building by Leighton Irwin and Roy K. Stevenson "The Jury considers that this is an unusual example of street architecture as it actually faces streets on all four elevations and presents a very interesting treatment of the various facades."[5]
A long pause caused by World War II and a slow return to a regular annual architecture awards in Victoria saw none given until 1954 at around which time the medal was renamed the 'Bronze Medal' or 'the medal'. During the 1950s, 1960s and 1970s few medals were awarded. It was not until 1987 that an annual medal was awarded consistently and named the Victorian Architecture Medal, and has been given annually until present.
In the 1930s the RIBA began awarding Street Architecture Awards and medals to international projects, including the British Medical Association (BMA) House at 137 Macquarie Street, Sydney, by architects Fowell and McConnel.[6] The award was presented in 1935 for buildings completed in the five years to end of 1933. This was the first time the award had been presented in New South Wales. The RIBA provided the architects with a bronze medal to be affixed to the building and a signed diploma. It was planned at the time for an award to be presented every three years to a new building in New South Wales.[7] Perth Girls' School[8] in Western Australia was awarded a RIBA Bronze Medal in 1939, for the period 1936–1938.[9]
Victorian Architecture Medal Winners (since 1987)
YEAR | WINNER | PROJECT | LOCATION | OTHER AIA AWARDS |
---|---|---|---|---|
2023 | Lyons with Koning Eizenberg Architecture, NMBW Architecture Studio, Greenaway Architects, Architects EAT, Aspect Studios and Glas Urban | University of Melbourne Student Precinct[11] | University of Melbourne, Carlton | Henry Bastow Award for Educational Architecture, Heritage Architecture Award for Creative Adaptation, Joseph Reed Award for Urban Design, Commendation Public Architecture |
2022 | Noxon Giffen Architects (with McGregor Coxall) | Grampians Peaks Trail Stage 2[12] | Grampians National Park (Gariwerd) | Regional Prize |
2021 | Grimshaw in collaboration with Monash University | Woodside Building for Technology and Design | 20 Exhibition Walk, Monash University Clayton Campus | Melbourne Prize, Colorbond® Award for Steel Architecture, Award for Educational Architecture, 2021 Sir Zelman Cowen Award for Public Architecture, Australian Institute of Architects (National Awards) |
2020 | Kerstin Thompson Architects | Broadmeadows Town Hall | 10 Dimboola Road, Broadmeadows | Public Architecture Commendation |
2019 | Peter Elliott Architecture and Urban Design | Parliament of Victoria Members' Annexe | Spring Street, East Melbourne | Melbourne Prize, Joseph Reed Award for Urban Design, William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Allan and Beth Coldicutt Award for Sustainable Architecture |
2018 | Lyons with NMBW Architecture Studio, Harrison and White, MvS Architects and Maddison Architects | New Academic Street, RMIT University | Bowen Street, Melbourne | Melbourne Prize (Joint Winner), Joseph Reed Award for Urban Design, Henry Bastow Award for Educational Architecture, Interior Architecture — Architecture Award |
2017 | Silver Thomas Hanley, DesignInc & McBride Charles Ryan[13] | Victorian Comprehensive Cancer Centre (VCCC) | 305 Grattan Street, Melbourne | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture |
2016 | ARM Architecture | Geelong Library and Heritage Centre | 51 Little Malop Street, Geelong | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Marion Mahony Award for Interior Architecture, Regional Prize |
2015 | ARM Architecture | Shrine of Remembrance, Galleries of Remembrance | Birdwood Avenue, Melbourne | Melbourne Prize, William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, John George Knight Award (Heritage Architecture), Urban Design Architecture Award |
2014 | McBride Charles Ryan | Dallas Brooks Community Primary School | 26—36 King Street, Dallas | Melbourne Prize, William Wardell Award for Public Architecture |
2013 | Sean Godsell Architects in association with Peddle Thorp Architects | RMIT University Design Hub (Building 100) | 150 Victoria Street, Carlton | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Colorbond Award for Steel Architecture |
2012 | Billard Leece Partnership and Bates Smart[14] | Royal Children's Hospital | 50 Flemington Road, Parkville | Melbourne Prize, William Wardell Award for Public Architecture |
2011 | Cox Architecture | AAMI Park | Olympic Boulevard, Melbourne | Melbourne Prize, William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Colorbond Award for Steel Architecture |
2010 | Woods Bagot and NH Architecture | Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Centre | 1 Convention Centre Place, South Wharf | Melbourne Prize, William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Steel Architecture Award, Award for Sustainable Architecture |
2009 | ARM Architecture | Melbourne Recital Centre and MTC Theatre Project, (Southbank Theatre) | 31 Sturt Street, Southbank | Marion Mahony Award for Interior Architecture, William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Joseph Reed Award for Urban Design |
2008 | John Wardle Architecture | Nigel Peck Centre for Learning and Leadership, Melbourne Grammar School | 47 Domain Road, Melbourne | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, National AIA Award for Public Architecture, Emil Sodersten Award for Interior Architecture |
2007 | Grimshaw Jackson Joint Venture | Southern Cross Station[15] | Spencer Street, Melbourne | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Walter Burley Griffin Award for Urban Design (National Award)[16] |
2006 | Wood Marsh Architecture | Yve Apartments[17][18] | 576–578 St Kilda Road, Melbourne | Harold Desbrowe–Annear Residential Award, Residential Architecture — Multiple Housing (National) |
2005 | McBride Charles Ryan Architecture and Interior Design | Templestowe Park Primary School Multipurpose Hall | 399 Church Road, Templestowe | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture |
2004 | ARM Architecture | Shrine of Remembrance Visitor Centre and Garden Courtyard | Birdwood Avenue, Melbourne | Melbourne Prize, John George Knight Award (Heritage Architecture), William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Walter Burley Griffin Award for Urban Design (National) |
2003 | Lab Architecture Studio in association with Bates Smart | Federation Square | Flinders Street & St Kilda Road, Melbourne | Melbourne Prize, Joseph Reed Award for Urban Design, Mahony Griffin Award for Interior Architecture (National Award) |
2002 | Lyons | Victoria University Online Training Centre, St Albans Campus[19] | University Boulevard, St Albans | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture |
2001 | Denton Corker Marshall | Melbourne Museum | 11 Nicholson Street, Carlton Gardens, Carlton | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Sir Zelman Cowen Award for Public Buildings (National) |
2000 | FIELD Consultants | Holyoake Cottage, Eaglemont[20] | Eaglemont, Victoria | Residential: Harold Desbrowe–Annear Award |
1999 | Nation Fender Katsalidis Architects | Ian Potter Museum of Art | Swanston Street, Melbourne | Melbourne Prize, Commendation for Public Buildings (National) |
1998 | Wood Marsh/Pels Innes Neilson Kosloff | Eastern Freeway Extension (Stage 3) Sound Barriers | M3 Eastern Freeway (Doncaster Road to Springvale Road), Doncaster, Doncaster East and Blackburn North | Walter Burley Griffin Award for Urban Design (National) |
1997 | John Wardle Architecture | Isaacson Davis Residence[21] | Balnarring, Mornington Peninsula | Harold Desbrowe–Annear Award |
1996 | ARM Architecture | Storey Hall (RMIT Building 16) | 336 Swanston Street, Melbourne | William Wardell Award for Public Architecture, Marion Mahony Award for Interior Architecture, Interior Award (National) |
1995 | Edmond & Corrigan in association with Demaine Partnership | RMIT Building 8 | 360 Swanston Street, Melbourne | Walter Burley Griffin Award for Urban Design (National), Award for Institutional Alterations & Extensions, City of Melbourne Award for Institutional Buildings |
1994 | Williams & Boag | Tyne Street Multiple Housing | 8–28 Tyne Street, Carlton | Walter Burley Griffin Award for Urban Design 1994 (National), Merit Award for Multiple Residential 1993, City of Melbourne Building and Planning Awards Merit Award—Multiple Dwellings Category 1994 |
1993 | Crone Ross | Chapel of The Holy Trinity | Trinity Grammar, Kew | |
1992 | Tompkins Shaw and Evans/Daryl Jackson | MCG Southern Stand Redevelopment (Great Southern Stand/Shane Warne Stand) | Brunton Avenue, East Melbourne | Sir Zelman Cowan Award for Public Architecture (National) 1993, Victoria Enduring Architecture Award 2020 |
1991 | Peter Elliott | Carlton Baths and Community Centre[22] | 248 Rathdowne Street, Carlton | 1991 New Institutional Award [merit], 1991 BHP Steel Profile Architecture of the Decade Awards 1981–1991 [highly commended], 1991 BHP Steel Sheet and Coil Products Division and Metal Building [merit] |
1990 | ARM Architecture | Brunswick Community Health Centre | 11 Glenlyon Road, Brunswick, Victoria | Institutional Award[23] |
1989 | Edmond & Corrigan with Ministry for Housing and Construction | Dandenong College of TAFE, Stage 3 | Dandenong, Victoria | Sir Zelman Cowan Award for Public Architecture (National), Victoria Chapter Outstanding Architecture — New Institutional Category |
1988 | Katsalidis & Partners | Deutscher Fine Art Gallery & Residence[24] | 7 Elm Street, Carlton | |
1987 | Gregory Burgess | Catholic Church of St Michael & St John [25] | 9 McLachlan Street, Horsham |
Architecture Medal Winners, (1954–1986)
In the period following World War II and the resumption of some awards in 1954, the Street Architecture Medal was dropped as an award, with more than 12 years passing since it was last judged. Perhaps responding to the rise of modernism and new concerns in architecture it was seen as outmoded and out of date. There was a widespread use of the term 'Bronze Medal' often for housing projects, although it is unclear if these medals equate to the status of the current Victoria Architecture Medal.
YEAR | WINNER | PROJECT | LOCATION | OTHER AIA AWARDS |
---|---|---|---|---|
1986–1976 | NO AWARDS | |||
1975 | Yuncken Freeman | BHP House† | 140 William Street, Melbourne |
|
1974–1969 | NO AWARDS | |||
1968 | McGlashan Everist | Heide II† | Heide Gallery, 7 Templestowe Road, Bulleen |
|
1968 | Romberg & Boyd | Fletcher House†† | 8 Avonbury Court, Brighton |
|
1967 | Yuncken Freeman | Royal Insurance Group† | 430—444 Collins Street, Melbourne |
|
1966–1964 | NO AWARDS | |||
1963 | McGlashan Everist | Grimwade House[29][30][31] | 28–54 Dundas Street, Rye, Victoria | |
1962–1955 | NO AWARDS | |||
1954 | Grounds, Romberg & Boyd | House and Four Apartments (Roy Grounds House)[32] | 24 Hill Street, Toorak |
Notes:
Victorian Architecture Medal
- Street Architecture Medal concept dropped by 1954.
- Definition of award changed to consider private and residential projects.
- No 'Victorian Architecture Medals' were awarded between the years 1955–1962 and 1964–1986 (according to the AIA).
- † Bronze Medals were awarded during periods when the AIA have stated no VAMs were awarded.
- †† Bronze Medal for The Age/RAIA House of the Year.
- Status of Bronze Medals to be determined.
RVIA Street Architecture Medal Winners (1929—1942)
YEAR | WINNER | PROJECT | LOCATION | |
---|---|---|---|---|
1953–1943 | NO AWARDS | |||
1942 | Meldrum and Noad | Western Branch of the National Bank of Australasia Limited | 460 Collins Street, Melbourne (corner of William Street)[34] | |
1941 | Stephenson and Turner | The King George V Jubilee Maternal and Infant Welfare Pathological Building | Women's Hospital, Melbourne[35] | |
1940 | Edward F. Billson | Sanitarium Health Food Company Building | 3475 Warburton Highway, Warburton[36][37] | |
1939 | Peck and Kempter and AC Leith and Associates | Heidelberg Town Hall and Municipal Offices | 275 Heidelberg Road, Ivanhoe | |
1938 | Bates, Smart and McCutcheon | Second Church of Christ, Scientist, Melbourne[38][39] | 41 Cookson Street, Camberwell | |
1937 | Leighton Irwin and Roy K. Stevenson | Royal Australasian College of Surgeons Building[40] | 250/290 Spring Street, East Melbourne | |
1936 | Godfrey and Spowers (design architects: Norman H Seabrook and WR Godfrey) | Bank of New South Wales office | 368–374 Collins Street, Melbourne since demolished[41] | |
1935 | A&K Henderson and Partners (Kingsley Henderson) | Shell Corner | Corner of Bourke and Williams Street, Melbourne, demolished 1958[42] | |
1934 | Bates, Smart and McCutcheon (Walter Osbert McCutcheon) | Buckley & Nunn Building (now part of David Jones) | 294–312 Bourke Street, Melbourne | |
1933 | Sidney Smith, Ogg and Serpell | Port of Melbourne Authority Building | 29–31 Market Street, Melbourne (now the Port Apartments) | |
1932 | Bates, Smart and McCutcheon | AMP Building [43] | 419–429 Collins Street, Melbourne | |
1931 | A&K Henderson and Partners | Lyric House[44] | 250 Collins Street, Melbourne | |
1930 | E. Evan Smith, Chief Architect; designed and constructed by the Public Works Department of Victoria | Emily McPherson College of Domestic Economy (RMIT Building 13) | 405 Russell Street, Melbourne[45] | |
1929 | WAB Blackett[46] and WB Forster | Francis House[47] | 107 Collins Street, Melbourne |
Notes:
RVIA Street Architecture Medal
- No Street Architecture Medals awarded during the war years and post–war years between 1942–1953.
- Five of the 12 awards were given to buildings on Collins Street, Melbourne.
See also
References
- "Victoria Architecture Awards". Architecture.com.au. 2023. Retrieved 8 July 2023.
- "Royal Institute of British Architects (RIBA) Street Architecture Medal, RIBA Ref No RIBA97291". Royal Institute of British Architects [RIBA]. Retrieved 26 July 2023.
- "The R.V.I.A. Victorian Street Architecture Medal, 1929". Journal of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects. Melbourne, Victoria: Royal Victorian Institute of Architects (in alliance with the Royal Institute of British Architects). 27 (3 (July 1929)): 60. July 1929 – via Trove.
- Tibbits, George (1979). "William Arthur Mordey Blackett". Australian Dictionary of Biography. Retrieved 14 August 2023.
- "Street Architecture Medal 1937 Award". Journal of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects. 35 (6): 220 – via Trove.
- "BMA House". PocketOz, Pocket Guide to Sydney. Retrieved 25 July 2023.
- "R.I.B.A. Plaque". Building: The Magazine for the Architect, Builder, Property Owner and Merchant. 56 (334): 69. 12 June 1935 – via Trove.
- Murray, Andrew (26 January 2010). "Perth Girls' School". Perths Best Architecture. Retrieved 26 July 2023.
- "Perth Girls' School (former), East Perth". Register of Heritage Places, Western Australia: 4. 28 February 1995 – via State Heritage WA.
- "Victorian Architecture Medal Winner" (PDF). Architecture.com.au. 2023. Retrieved 8 July 2023.
- "Victorian Architecture Medal awarded to University of Melbourne Student Precinct". OVGA Office of Victoria Government Architect. June 2023. Retrieved 8 July 2023.
- "Grampians Peaks Trail Stage 2". Noxon. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- "2017 Victorian Architecture Awards Winners List" (PDF). Architecture.com.au. June 2017. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- "2012 Victorian Architecture Awards Announced". Architecture.com.au. 30 June 2012. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- "Stations curves prove real head turner". The Age. 14 July 2007. Retrieved 8 July 2023.
- "Walter Burley Griffin Award for Urban Design 2007". ArchitectureAU.com.au. 1 November 2007. Retrieved 5 August 2023.
- "Yve Apartments project page". Wood Marsh. Retrieved 11 July 2023.
- "Yve website". Yve.com.au. Retrieved 11 July 2023.
- "Victoria University Online Training Facility project page". Lyons. Retrieved 25 July 2023.
- "RAIA State Awards, Victoria, 2000". Architecture AU. 1 July 2000. Retrieved 10 July 2023.
- "Architectural resource package: Isaacson/Davis Beach House, Balnarring Victoria, Owners: Isaacson/ Davis, Architect: John Wardle, Construction Date: 1996" (PDF). University of Tasmania. Retrieved 26 July 2023.
- "Carlton Baths and Family Resource Centre". Peter Elliott Architecture. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- "ARM Architecture Awards list". ARM Architecture. Retrieved 1 August 2023.
- Landy, Samantha (5 December 2019). "Deutscher Fine Art Gallery Carlton conversion a work of art". Herald Sun. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- "Catholic Church of St Michael and St John, Horsham". Gregory Burgess Architect. Retrieved 10 July 2023.
- "Victorian Architecture Medal Winners" (PDF). Architecture.com.au. 2023. Retrieved 8 July 2023.
- "Melbourne's Marvellous Modernism, A Comparative Analysis of Post-War Modern Architecture in Melbourne's CBD 1955–1975" (PDF). National Trust: 40, 43. September 2014.
- "Melbourne's Marvellous Modernism, A Comparative Analysis of Post-War Modern Architecture in Melbourne's CBD 1955–1975" (PDF). National Trust: 40, 43. September 2014.
- "Grimwade House". McGlashan and Everist Pty Ltd.
- Wee, Michael (2014). "Grimwade House". Michael Wee Photography. Retrieved 20 July 2023.
- "Grimwade House". Victorian Heritage Database. 14 May 2009. Retrieved 8 September 2023.
- "Grounds House, Toorak, 1952-–53". Museums Victoria. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- "Victorian Architecture Medal" (PDF). Architecture.com.au. 2023. Retrieved 8 July 2023.
- "The National Bank of Australasia Ltd. Melbourne — Western Branch". Journal of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects. 37 (8, 9): 218–227. October–November 1939.
- "Pathological Building of the Women's Hospital". Journal of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects. 37 (3): 74–86. May 1939 – via Trove.
- petrolhead (14 June 2010). "Sanitarium factory Warburton Australia". Derelict Places. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
- "3475 Warburton Highway, Warburton, Victoria". Google Maps. June 2021. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
- Akehurst, Christopher (26 March 2020). "Second Church of Christ, Scientist, Camberwell". Here Today... (blog). Retrieved 26 July 2023.
- "Architecture Medal, Church Gains Award, Firm's third success". The Age. 25 March 1939. p. 24. Retrieved 14 August 2023.
- "1937 Street Architecture Medal from the Journal of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects.Vol. 35, No. 6". Trove. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- "Minutes — General Meeting of the Institute". Journal of the Royal Victorian Institute of Architects. 35 (1): 37. 27 January 1937 – via Trove.
- Sievers, Wolfgang (1 January 1956). "Old Shell Building, corner of Bourke and William Street, Melbourne, Victoria, 1956 [picture]". Trove. Retrieved 12 July 2023.
- "Former Australian Mutual Provident Society Headquarters". National Trust database. Retrieved 10 July 2023.
- Storey, Rohan (17 February 2020). "Shopfront Lyric House, Collins Street". Storey of Melbourne (blog). Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- "Building 13 (Emily McPherson)". RMIT. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- Tibbits, George (2006). "William Arthur Mordey Blackett". Australian Dictionary of Biography. Retrieved 24 July 2023.
- Storey, Rohan (25 September 2019). "Francis House, Collins Street". Storey of Melbourne (blog).