Up to Now

The album marks the band's 15 year music career. It is a reminder to newer fans that the band had made two albums before Final Straw, before achieving any commercial success. In line with the 15 years they have been recording, the album features 2 CDs with 15 songs on each, with 3 brand new tracks.[1] The band felt it was a good time for such a release as their newer material was heading towards new, unexplored musical styles.[1]

To come up with a track list for the album, each member compiled one individually, initially coming up with almost the same song selections.[2] According to guitarist Nathan Connolly, the only differences in opinion on song selections among the band members arose on songs from the earliest albums.[3] Forty songs were initially selected, but they realized it wouldn't be practically possible to include all of them. They were whittled down to thirty, some reluctantly.[4] One of these was "Make This Go on Forever". Vocalist Gary Lightbody explained that they did it as to evenly represent all their albums. The final chosen songs are from all five studio albums, past b-sides and rarities, apart from three new recordings.[5] They also felt the song selection should draw all sorts of fans; those who've supported from the start and those who might be hearing about the band for the first time, which was the reason for comparatively less representation of songs from the early albums.[6] Commenting on fans' arguments about leaving singles "How to Be Dead" and "One Night is Not Enough" off the album, Lightbody said that they couldn't please everyone.[2] Drummer Jonny Quinn remembers enjoying the selection process as he went back to listen their older songs he hadn't heard recently.[7]

Lightbody has made it clear that the album isn't a greatest hits record, and has expressed his dislike for such. According to him, the compilation is a way to leave the last 15 years behind, and looking forward to 15 years in the future. The album's title, Up to Now was specifically chosen to indicate the band has more to offer in the future, and that it wasn't a way of saying goodbye.[9] The band believes that the album signifies a portrait of the band, who they are, "warts and all".[10] Lightbody said it represents the band making a statement, explaining: "We've climbed a hill and now we're looking back and taking in the view for a bit. It's nice to show people that we didn't just arrive overnight".[11] The artwork for the album was revealed on 25 September 2009.[12]

The Pub Quiz winners saw a Snow Patrol concert at London's Royal Albert Hall

To promote the album, a competition exclusive for members on the Snow Patrol mailing list was held. Fans wishing to enter the competition had to sign up and answer a question.[13] The competition closed on 9 October 2009[14] and its winner received a drum skin, signed by all members of the band, as well as a photograph proving its authenticity, taken on the band's North American Tour of September–October 2009.[13] On 16 October 2009, a competition called the "Up to Now Pub Quiz" was launched on Facebook. Fans were required to create teams of five, and were posed with ten questions each week, related to the band's entire career. The team with the most correct answers at the end flew to London to see a Snow Patrol concert at the Royal Albert Hall, with a certain part of travel cost paid. The team was allotted their own private box at the venue, and got to meet the band afterward. Along the same lines, a Swiss radio station 20 Minuten hosted a similar competition for listeners. They had a pair of tickets for the concert for the Royal Albert Hall concert of 24 November to give away. All flight and hotel accommodation costs were paid for by the radio station.[15] The band also played an intimate, acoustic show at King's Head in Crouch End, London on 4 November.[16] Tickets for this show could only be obtained via two competitions, one organized on Play.com and the other on the band's official website. Both involved answering a simple question.[17][18] On 8 November 2009, the band released a second application for the iPhone.[19] An online application was also made, where users could manually create their own snowflakes.[20]

The album was made available in three formats:

• Standard – Two CDs featuring thirty tracks.
• Digipak – Two CDs, and a DVD containing documentaries and live footage.
• Box set – Limited edition heavyweight box, numbered and wrapped in cloth. Contains three CDs, three heavyweight LPs, two DVDs, a lithograph print by Bradley Quinn and an LP sized booklet.

The additional DVD in the digipak format contains the animated film for "The Lightning Strike" and previously unseen live footage.[27] The box-set went on pre-order on 11 September 2009 and was priced at £49.99. The first 100 sold boxes were individually numbered and signed by all band members.[28] The DVDs have no region restrictions,[29] and can be played in any part of the world.[30] The album contained three new songs: "Just Say Yes", "Give Me Strength" and "Dark Roman Wine".[31] Additionally, a solo rendition of "An Olive Grove Facing the Sea", performed by Gary Lightbody was also released through the album.[32] Also featured is the cover of Beyoncé Knowles' "Crazy in Love", which became a hit in the hip hop community. Lightbody felt it would be one of the most sought-after songs on the collection.[33]

Lightbody is pleased with "Give Me Strength" and has named it [probably] his most favorite song by the band.[6] The song is about everyone who's "been there", his love for his bandmates, especially Jonny Quinn, whom he considers his big brother. He has said that it was "long overdue". The song is lyrically similar to "Weather to Fly" by Elbow. Lightbody is a huge fan of the band and is "head-over-heels in love" with them. He has credited the band for being the reason for "most of the things [he does]" and does not deny that he may have subconsciously based "Give Me Strength" on "Weather to Fly".[2]

Professional ratings

Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[35]
Drowned in Sound	6/10[36]
IndieLondon	4.5/5[37]
Pitchfork	5.1/10[38]
PopMatters	7/10[39]
Rolling Stone	[40]
Stuff.co.nz	[41]
Sunday Mercury	Favourable[42]
The Border Mail	4/5[43]
The List	[44]

Critical reception towards Up to Now was "generally favorable" according to the review collecting site Metacritic, where it holds a score of 62.[45] IndieLondon's Jack Foley gave it a 4.5/5 rating, and found it "classy". He praised it for not being a generic compilation album, noting the inclusion of the band's lesser known songs. He praised the band's willingness to tread unfamiliar territory (with "Just Say Yes") and found the synth a "nice touch".[37] Rolling Stone reviewer Jon Dolan found the set "claustrophobic" and awarded it three stars out of five.[40] AllMusic's Andrew Leahey gave the album a positive review, and also gave it three stars. He felt it indicated the band's growth over the years. He found the new song "Give Me Strength" as one of the best songs the band has written in years.[35] The Border Mail gave it 4 out of 5 and found the set "expansive".[43] Drowned in Sound called "An Olive Grove Facing the Sea" a classic and named it the song to be played to Snow Patrol detractors.[36] Stuff.co.nz gave it 4 stars out of 5. Reviewer Kris Hall said that the album looked like a "shameless cash grab" at the first look, but turns out to be different. He noted that the diverse material meant that there was something for everyone. He also said wrote the live renditions of "Run" and "Chasing Cars" were not be missed.[41] However, Scottish magazine The List in a negative review said that it was still a typical greatest hits album.[44] In Pitchfork's mixed review, Tom Breihan wrote that the album was too long and "overstuffed".[38] The inclusion of "Crazy in Love" was praised in most reviews, and was seen as an indication of the band's lighter, fun side.[35][36][37][41][43] However, in Pitchfork's review, it was called "limp" and "unfunny".[38] Hot Press' Peter Murphy wrote he would have liked to see the duet "Some Surprise" included.[46]

On national record charts, it peaked at #5 in the Netherlands and Ireland.[47][48] In the UK, it peaked at #3.[49] It also reached the top 40 in Switzerland, peaking at #36.[47]

Snow Patrol at the Royal Albert Hall on 24 November 2009

The band "looked back" by playing a special tour, called the Reworked Tour.[1] It saw the band play "reworked" versions of songs that spanned their full career, including songs from side-project The Reindeer Section.[50] The songs were reconstructed using strings, brass and choir.[51] The band visited a south London studio to rehearse the reworked songs.[52][53] Touring began in mid-November, and continued till early December. The band played without any support act. They took the stage twice between an interval, accompanied by 11 special musical guests,[54] including Iain Archer, members of Belle & Sebastian, Teenage Fanclub and Idlewild.[55]

• Up to Now at Metacritic
• Make Your Own Snowflake app