Rogers: The Musical

Jonathan Igla, the head writer of the Marvel Studios Disney+ miniseries Hawkeye (2021), first conceived of an idea for a fictional Broadway musical centered on Rogers after noticing a billboard for the Broadway musical Hamilton (2015).[7] A real-life Broadway musical based on the Marvel Comics character Captain America had previously been in development in 1985, but never came to fruition.[8] Igla then imagined what it would feel like to live in the MCU and how people would feel inspired by Rogers to create a musical based on him to inspire and entertain audiences. He considered the musical as a way to introduce emotional and psychological information through something disguised as funny, exciting, and surprising, like Clint Barton / Hawkeye's grief and guilt over Natasha Romanoff / Black Widow's death.[9] Director Rhys Thomas then pitched the idea as a joke to Marvel Studios president Kevin Feige, who was enthused and quickly gave the go-ahead.[10][11]

"Save the City"
"Save the City" as performed in "Never Meet Your Heroes"
Song by Adam Pascal, Ty Taylor, Rory Donovan, Derek Klena, Bonnie Milligan, Christopher Sieber, and Shayna Steele
from the album Hawkeye: Vol. 2 (Episodes 4–6) (Original Soundtrack)
Released	November 24, 2021 (2021-11-24)
Genre	Show tune
Length	4:26
Label	Hollywood Marvel Music
Composer(s)	Marc Shaiman
Lyricist(s)	Marc Shaiman Scott Wittman
Producer(s)	Marc Shaiman Scott M. Riesett
Video
"Save The City" (audio only) on YouTube

Feige had kept in contact with composer Marc Shaiman ever since both met in an event promoting Mary Poppins Returns (2018) for the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, and decided to enlist him for Hawkeye due to his Broadway credentials.[12] Shaiman and Scott Wittman then wrote a musical number from the fictional musical entitled "Save the City",[13] envisioning the song as the final number of the musical's first act.[14] At Marvel's suggestion, the song was set during the Battle of New York, as depicted in the film The Avengers (2012), which the composers agreed was a good moment to finish a musical's first act. Both immediately had the idea of New Yorkers requesting the Avengers' help, and wrote a verse and a chorus. While Shaiman normally sings while recording demos for his songs, he thought the difficult notes of "Save the City" would not allow him to do so, so he reached out to Broadway performer Adam Pascal to sing on the demo; Ty Taylor was also included as the other main singer, with Rory Donovan singing Captain America's part. Wittman said the song tried to reflect New York City during the COVID-19 pandemic, "this kind of wishing that maybe the Avengers would come and take COVID away". He also added that it had to serve two purposes: be entertaining and make Barton feel uncomfortable.[15] "Save the City" was recorded before the stage performance was filmed in Atlanta, as COVID restrictions prevented the performers other than Pascal and Taylor from traveling to be a part of the filming.[12]

A portion of "Save the City" is shown in "Never Meet Your Heroes", the first episode of Hawkeye.[12] After numerous references to Rogers: The Musical in subsequent episodes,[16] "Save of City" is shown in full during the mid-credits scene of "So This Is Christmas?", the series finale.[17][18] Thomas had been unaware of the full performance's inclusion, since it was not the initial plan to include it, and was "slightly conflicted about" its inclusion given he had felt the credits slot was being reserved for a scene to tease another MCU project, but understood it ended up being "a fun release at the end, and a nice way to send people off".[19][20] Hollywood Records and Marvel Music released "Save the City" as a digital single on November 24, 2021, the day of the series' premiere,[21] with it also included on the Hawkeye: Vol. 2 (Episodes 4–6) (Original Soundtrack) album that released on December 22, 2021.[22]

The cast of the performance includes Pascal and Taylor as the two leads,[18] Tom Feeney as Rogers, Aaron Nedrick as Tony Stark / Iron Man, Jason Scott McDonald as Thor, Harris Turner as Bruce Banner / Hulk, Meghan Manning as Romanoff, Avery Gillham as Barton, Jordan Chin as Loki, Nico DeJesus as Lang, and several extras as Chitauri warriors.[23][12] Other performers include Rory Donovan, Derek Klena, Bonnie Milligan, Christopher Sieber, and Shayna Steele.[24] Fra Fee, who portrays Kazimierz "Kazi" Kazimierczak in the series, was disappointed that he could not participate in the musical's production.[25]

Dais Johnston of Inverse enjoyed seeing the MCU from the perspective of its citizens, praising Rogers: The Musical's use of "meta-commentary".[26] Jenelle Riley at Variety felt despite the small amount shown, Rogers: The Musical "achieves something sublime: It's silly but self-aware; a hilarious commentary on consumerism airing on a network owned by Disney; and, perhaps most important, a genuinely clever and catchy number."[27] Rachel Leishman of The Mary Sue wrote that the musical scene in Hawkeye was "so bad it's good", highlighting Barton's reaction to seeing Romanoff's portrayal.[28] Vulture's Jackson McHenry hoped that a potential second season of Hawkeye would answer his questions about the musical.[29] Brady Langmann of Esquire predicted that Rogers: The Musical would lead to an MCU musical film.[30] Mashable's Alexis Nedd envisioned a full-length version of the musical as opening with a flashback of a young Rogers and ending with him embarking on a new mission.[31]

Upon the release of the trailer for Hawkeye, viewers were drawn to the fictional musical,[32][33][34] with many noting its similarities to Hamilton.[35][36] "Save the City" generated over 1 million on-demand official streams in the U.S., according to Luminate.[37] Some viewers expressed disappointment at "Save the City" being the mid-credits scene of "So This Is Christmas?", a response Shaiman described as "bittersweet".[38]

Shortly after Hawkeye's release, executive producer Trinh Tran expressed interest in a real-life version of Rogers: The Musical,[42] while Shaiman and Wittman expressed interest in writing a full-length version of the musical.[43] Disney Live Entertainment began inquiring with Marvel Studios about creating a full version of the musical following the D23 performance of "Save the City".[44]

In February 2023, it was announced that a one-act stage show version of Rogers: The Musical would be performed at the Hyperion Theater in Hollywood Land at Disney California Adventure for a limited time,[45] created and directed by Jordan Peterson for Disney Live Entertainment.[37][2] It features a book by Hunter Bell along with the songs "Save the City", "Star Spangled Man" by Alan Menken and David Zippel from the film Captain America: The First Avenger (2011), and five original songs with music by Christopher Lennertz and lyrics by Peterson, Lennertz, and Alex Karukas.[46][41] Lennertz also served as conductor and arranger for Rogers: The Musical,[37] with Karukas also arranging the music. Orchestrations for the musical were done by Michael Starobin, Charlie Rosen, Macy Schmidt, and Andrew Kinney.[5] Lennertz previously composed the music for the Agent Carter One-Shot (2013) and television series (2015–2016).[47]

Before the show began, "period-appropriate jazzy tunes" were played through an onstage radio, one of which referenced the Elias & Co. store on Buena Vista Street in Disney California Adventure.[37] The performance includes the Starkettes, who serve as a Greek chorus for the show,[48] Rogers, Peggy Carter,[1] Abraham Erskine,[2] Nick Fury, and select members of the Avengers,[1] with the character's costumes resembling those from the films in a "fun, more casual" look.[49] Rogers: The Musical only features one cast (not typical for theme park shows, which usually have multiple performers for each role), many of whom were reportedly based out of New York and had Broadway experience.[50] The cast, as featured on the original cast album, includes: Bella Hicks and Krystle Rose' Simmons as the Starkettes; Josey Montana McCoy as pre-serum Rogers and Luke Monday as Rogers / Captain America; Rachel Wirtz as Carter; and Jay Donnell as Fury, among additional ensemble members.[6] Sarah Kobayashi from Disney Live Entertainment served as choreographer, with her choreography utilizing the show's different time periods to incorporate period-appropriate dance styles "with a modern twist". Kobayashi also tailored specific movements that would make sense for each character; for example, Thor can be seen joyfully dancing while Loki makes "sly moves".[27] Layered scenery, physical set pieces, and a video screen were used to create each setting in the show.[49] Bell chose to focus the one-act on the love story of Rogers and Carter since "[g]reat love stories make great musicals".[27]

The new songs include: "U-S-Opening Night", sung by the Starkettes to frame the show;[2][5] "I Want You", Rogers' "I Want" song about enlisting in the army;[2] "What You Missed", sung by Fury to explain to a recently awakened Rogers what he has missed while he was frozen for 70 years, described by Lennertz as a patter song that meets "Uptown Funk".[37] It includes excerpts of the "I Love Lucy Theme" by Eliot Daniel and "The Imperial March" by John Williams;[5] "End of the Line", described as a "reflective twist" on Rogers' fate; and "Just One Dance", a ballad about the "lost romance" between Rogers and Carter.[2] The music was described as "big band jazz, modern funk, [and] classic orchestra",[49][37] and was performed by a 60-piece orchestra.[49] Alan Silvestri's Captain America and Avengers themes are featured in the music.[2]

Rogers: The Musical ran approximately 30 minutes and premiered on June 30, 2023, as part of Disney's centennial celebrations.[1] Performances occurred multiple times a day on Tuesday through Saturday most weeks, and ran until August 31, 2023.[1][41] Themed food was made available at various locations around the park, as well as a "Premium Viewing Experience" package that offered a souvenir popcorn bucket and priority seating for the show,[41] in addition to themed merchandise.[51] A longer version of the musical during development had a larger role for Bucky Barnes. His role was ultimately reduced in the one-act because of time constraints, with lines he said in the films given to Carter, which allowed the creatives to feature them. Lennertz was hopeful an expanded role for Barnes in a future version of the show would be able to include a song with him and Rogers.[52]

An original cast album of Rogers: The Musical was released digitally by Walt Disney Records on September 15, 2023,[6] which was produced by Matthew P. Selby, Lennertz, and Karukas.[53]

Rogers: The Musical was noted for its direction and production value, despite being a theme park show. Dirk Libbey at CinemaBlend called it "a fantastic piece of musical theater", being impressed by what Disney Live Entertainment created, noting it "raises the bar of what a stage show at a theme park can be".[55] Reviewing the show for the Los Angeles Times, Todd Martens said "there's plenty in these 30 minutes to smile at", with the show "lean[ing] heavily into theater tropes rather than contemporary theme park trickery", such as its "clever use of projections", and more contemporary costuming, which added to its charm.[56] Pam Kragen at The San Diego Union-Tribune felt, "As theme park shows go, Rogers: The Musical is a good one, thanks to its familiar storyline, comic book-inspired scenic design, special effects and quick pacing. Director Jordan Peterson has imbued the show with winking humor, but not at the expense of the characters who are presented with humble authenticity."[51] The Orange County Register's Brady Macdonald said Rogers: The Musical is "the Marvel musical you didn't know you were waiting for and won't be able to stop talking about. The breezy and brisk theme park show expertly walks a fine line, taking itself seriously, but not too seriously."[57] Game Rant's Anthony Taormina said, "With impeccable choreography, impressive sets, and endearing performances, Rogers: The Musical is another must-see at Disney's California parks."[58]

Jenelle Riley at Variety said the musical "truly has a Broadway vibe" and gave praise to the ASL interpreters who were able to rely both the dialogue and emotions of the musical with their faces and signing.[27] IGN's Joshua Yehl called it "the best Marvel musical ever put to stage", enjoying how many of its comics and MCU inspirations translated to the musical format.[4] Reviewing the musical for Gizmodo, Sabina Graves said it was a "surprisingly uplifting one-act parody" and "a worthy Disney Parks musical".[59] Many reviewers hoped the one-act led to a full-fledged Rogers: The Musical or more musicals based on Marvel Comics.[27][4][50]

Bell's book and Lennertz's music was also praised. Keith Caulfield from Billboard called the one-act performance "full of goofy humor and a range of musical styles".[37] The book was noted for being earnest and having "heart",[51][57][2] such as the Rogers-Carter love story that added to what was in the films "in some surprising ways",[58][59] and Bell being able to add "fresh and unexpected turns" to the story familiar to MCU fans.[51] However, the condensed runtime drew some criticism for not being able to linger on many moments for too long,[55] with Martens saying "the show feels heavily expository and plot-driven" and "like a 'greatest hits' compendium of Captain America moments", which was likely due to needing to fit within the theme park medium.[56] Yehl enjoyed the performances by both actors portraying Rogers, with both "do[ing] an excellent job of channeling Steve's effortless earnestness and heroic attitude".[4] Fury in the show was compared to Genie from the Aladdin (2011) musical.[2] Lennertz's music was likened to songs that would be heard in musicals performing on Broadway.[55][2][58] Fury's song "What You Missed" was considered a stand out,[48][56][58][27][4] though Martens felt despite this, none of the new songs reached the heights of "Save the City" and that much of the musical felt like "puzzle pieces constructed around" the use of that song.[56] Yehl called "End of the Line" with the two Rogers actors having a duet together "a frankly ridiculous moment, but it's so very Marvel and is used to such great effect that it hits you in the feels nonetheless".[4] Graves said the song was "beautifully done" given it "could have so easily not worked".[59]