RentAHitman.com

RentAHitman.com was bought and registered by Bob Innes of Northern California on February 5, 2005, for US$9.20.[3][4] Innes had graduated from the Napa Valley police academy in 1999 but had failed to find employment and instead turned to a career in information technology.[4] He established the website with a group of friends on an IT training program. The domain was the possible location for a website for a company the friends would set up for a service either testing companies' online security measures (by carrying out "hits" on them) or for a service optimizing web traffic (ie. increasing the number of hits).[3][5] At the time Innes was also collecting domain names in the hope of selling them later for a profit.[3] Innes and his friends graduated in June 2005 and went their separate ways, without forming a company.[3][5] Innes retained ownership of the domain name and put it up for auction but received no offers.[3] He continued to maintain the domain in the hope of selling it in the future.[5]

Innes checked the email inbox he had associated with the website in 2008 and found he had 250–300 messages requesting the services of contract killers (i.e. hitmen) or asking for employment in the field. Many were jokey in nature and he did not find any of them alarming.[3] When he checked again in 2010 he found a message from a woman in Canada named Helen. She requested that he carry out the murders of three of her family members in the United Kingdom, claiming they had cheated her out of an inheritance.[5] Innes considered this request the first serious one he had received, as it gave the names and addresses of the targets.[3] He passed the details onto a friend who was a California police sergeant. The case was passed to the Canadian police who arrested Helen. She served four months in prison for soliciting murder before being extradited to the United Kingdom where she was wanted on other serious charges.[5][3]

After this case Innes decided to continue to run the website and to rebrand it as a fake contract killing agency.[5] He filled the site with jokes and clues that it was not legitimate. These included fake testimonials from satisfied customers and a claim that he is regulated by the "Hitman Information Privacy Protection Act", a play on the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act with which he was familiar through his work in medical IT.[3][4] The site claims the agency has "17,985 field operatives", which is actually the approximate number of American law enforcement agencies and offers discounts for groups, seniors, 'spring cleaning', and Air National Guardsmen.[4][3] In 2014 Innes added a "service request form" which requires a user's names, email address and phone number.[3] Innes uses the nom de plume "Guido Fanelli" on the site and for responses to enquiries.[3]

Innes received around 8–10 requests a month, for a total of around 700 by November 2021, including 400 via his service request form.[3] He removes obvious joke entries but replies to any enquiries that he considers to be serious.[3] He allows clients a 24 hour cooling off period after which he asks two questions: "Do you still require our services? And would you like me to place you in contact with a field operative for a free consultation?". If they reply in the affirmative he passes their details onto law enforcement.[5] Innes passes all requests involving minors to the police immediately.[4] Innes considers the site "a magnet for low-hanging fruit that are out there trying to harm other people" and said "I really didn’t think that people were gonna be that stupid. Boy, did they show me".[3][4] He covers all costs to keep the site running, though he accepts donations.[5] After receiving several emails from people who wished to be hired as hitmen, Innes added a "Careers" page to the website, with a fake employment application.[6]

Innes thinks around 10% of enquiries to the site result in a police investigation and considers that he has saved around 150 lives through the site.[5][7] For a time Innes received a lot of enquiries from Indonesia as a result of his site being mentioned in an Indonesian YouTube video about the dark web.[4] Innes thinks that around a dozen people have been arrested as a result of the website. There have been at least a few notable cases.[4][8]