Ramshackle Inn

George Batson, a former automat busboy then serving in the US Army Signal Corps, wrote the play in 1942 expressly for ZaSu Pitts.[10] Robert Reud announced on October 21, 1943, that he would produce and Arthur Sircom direct ZaSu Pitts in the play.[3]

By October 29, 1943, Frederick Fox had been signed to design the sets.[11] Producer Reud started rehearsals at the Ritz Theater on November 2, 1943,[12] though casting was still ongoing.[13] Corporal Batson, stationed at Fort Monmouth, had to apply for a pass from his commanding officer to attend the tryout.[14]

The first tryout opened in Boston at the Wilbur Theatre on November 22, 1943.[15] The local reviewer noted the audience's enthusiasm for a work that was neither original nor brilliant; its familiarty and stock characters seemed to be what they wanted.[15] After two weeks in Boston, the production moved to Philadelphia, where it opened at the Walnut Theatre on December 6, 1943.[8] The reviewer here was more critical of the play: "'Ramshackle Inn' is a rather ramshackle play, with its crazy quilt plot a farrago of odds and ends of wild melodrama and dizzy farce".[8] The author "has hit upon a few amusing wisecracks. But they are not sufficient to make the play.... hang together or give it the sustained excitement and tension necessary".[8]

After two weeks in Philadelphia, producer Reud announced the production would take a week off to rehearse new material provided by Owen Davis.[2] The revised play replaced the original Nazi spies and saboteurs with a black market liquour-cutting racket. It also dropped one featured character, Mr. Cosgrove, and introduced another, Arbothnot. Six members of the cast were replaced with new actors at this time. The producer then took the unusual step of having the revised production do a four-day tryout at Blair Junior High School auditorium in Norfolk, Virginia.[23] This surprisingly large facility held an audience of up to nine hundred when the revised play debuted there on December 27, 1943.[17] Local reviewer Warner Twyford was kind with the actors, but said of the play: "It is not funny enough to be crackerjack comedy, it is not scary enough to be exciting melodrama, it is not mysterious enough to be a mystery".[17]

The production then went to Richmond for two more days of tryouts, having shed and acquired a supporting actor along the way.[19] Once there, lead actress Luella Gear chose to depart, necessitating replacement Ruth Gates to go on with 24 hours notice.[24] Both local reviewers felt the acting and direction were ok, that star ZaSu Pitts provided sufficient drawing power, but the play itself was flawed.[19][24]

The play had its premiere at the Royale Theatre on January 5, 1944.[4] According to a columnist, there was some talk about Max Gordon scheduling his premiere of Ruth Gordon's Over 21 on the same date Reud had reserved for Ramshackle Inn,[25] but Reud later revealed he was a follower of Evangeline Adams and had chosen the date according to astrological principles.[fn 1][26]

Critical reception of the play was unanimous that ZaSu Pitts performed very well in a losing effort, the work itself being fatally flawed. Arthur Pollock of The Brooklyn Eagle said of ZaSu Pitts and the play that it was "no pearl of the comic spirit, but she is a charming buffoon and there are many people who will find the thing funny with her in it".[5] He also credited Pitts with carrying the whole show: "The dialogue has no spring in it whatever. Take away Miss Pitts and there is nothing".[5] Lewis Nichols of The New York Times expressed the hope Miss Pitts might have a better vehicle in her next Broadway appearance.[1] According to Nichols, "'Ramshackle Inn' quite often succeeds in being only sleepy when it means to be hair-raising, and silly when it means to be funny".[1]

John Chapman in the Daily News concurred with other reviewers that Miss Pitts' performance was the main draw, but also mentioned some able support from Joe Downing, Richard Rober, and Harlan Briggs.[4] He called Ramshackle Inn a "tumbledown play" and noted that the audience could only have "a merely mildly exciting time as the plot unfolded like one of Miss Pitts' knee joints".[4] However, there is nothing harder for critics to predict than the popular appeal of a comic farce. By the end of March 1944, Ramshackle Inn had reached its 100th performance, paid off all its production and tryout costs, and was still raking in between twelve and eighteen thousand dollars a week.[27]

The original Broadway run closed at the Royale on July 8, 1944, after 216 performances.[6] Columnist Jack O'Brien ascribed the Broadway closing to "torridity".[28]

Ramshackle Inn was adapted to an hour-long teleplay for the Philco Television Playhouse, with ZaSu Pitts, Joe Downing, Ralph Theadore, and Robert Toms reprising their roles.[30] It was broadcast live on January 2, 1949,[31] and featured Nancy Davis as Mary Temple, Vivian Vance as Joyce Rogers, Gordon Peters as Constable Small, with Lewis Charles, Richard Bishop, Michael Lawson, Joseph Sweeny, and Don De Leo.[32][33] Recorded on kinescope, it was later rebroadcast on local television stations.[34]