Me, Myself & I (Jive Jones song)

In the October 20, 2001, issue of Billboard, Taylor gave the album a "New & Noteworthy" designation, calling it "the kind of hit-or-miss novelty song that could storm the nation... or become a keepsake to show the grandkids".[2] Taylor noted the track's catchiness, commenting that it throws "more hooks around than a fishing trawler" and concluding that the song "has all the ingredients for an autumn party anthem" if it could gain traction on the radio.[2] Kirstie McAra, writing for Contactmusic.com, was critical of the Terminalhead 12" mix released in the United Kingdom, writing that the remixers were "breaking no boundaries" and calling the effects "uninteresting".[8]

The track was included on the 2001 popular music compilation Now That's What I Call Music! 8.[9] In retrospect, the song has been noted as an unlikely inclusion in the Now That's What I Call Music! series, given its low chart position in the United States.[9] Writing for Vulture in 2014, music journalist Dave Holmes ranked it the least successful song from its respective Now, considering it representative of 2001 radio and commenting that "if we’d allowed Sugar Ray to continue recording, they would have arrived at something like this", further comparing Jones to a combination of Crazy Town's Shifty Shellshock and The Noid.[9] Also in 2014, Bustle classified the song as the "Wait, What?" moment on Now 8, with a comment that "No seriously, you need to see this video.[10] That year, Billboard called the song "intensely strange" and listed it as one of the "Top 50 Forgotten Gems From The Now! Series".[1] In 2018, The Ringer ranked it the "least essential song" from Now 8.[11]

In the United States, the song was sent to contemporary hit radio on August 14, 2001.[12] In the August 17, 2001, issue of industry trade publication Radio & Records, an industry panel ranked the song at number five on their list of "Earpicks", songs they regarded as having hit potential.[13] That week, the song was the "Most Added" song of the week in the CHR/pop radio format.[3] Some stations, such as WYOY (Jackson, Mississippi) and WZYP (Huntsville, Alabama), began playing the song before its official add date, and reported favorable feedback from listeners.[3] Jive promoted the song mainly to CHR/pop stations, but also released it to alternative stations.[3] It ultimately reached number 40 on the Radio & Records pop chart on September 21, 2001, receiving 1,095 plays on monitored pop stations that week.[14]

Internationally, the single charted in the UK and the Netherlands.[15][16][17] The song entered the UK Singles Chart dated March 23, 2002, at its peak of number 77, before falling to number 100 in its second and final week on the tally.[15] In the Netherlands, the single reached peaks of number 12 and number 13, respectively, on the Dutch Single Top 100 and Dutch Top 40.[16][17]

The label's main marketing tool for the song was its music video, filmed on June 30, 2001, in Sun Valley, California, by director Nigel Dick.[3][18] It was placed in MTV's rotation beginning the week ending August 19, 2001, and reached number 35 on the MTV Video Monitor for the week ending September 30, 2001.[19][20] The video was further added to the Box Block for the week of August 27.[21]