My Songs Know What You Did in the Dark (Light Em Up)

The music video for the song is the first of the Young Blood Chronicles, an ongoing series with the band filming a video for every song on Save Rock and Roll. It begins late at night, with a figure – later revealed to be rapper 2 Chainz – walking away from a black van parked in a forest clearing. He starts a bonfire by pouring gasoline over a wood pile and lighting it up with a match. Two women then exit the van, carrying various musical instruments belonging to Fall Out Boy, among them the band's guitars, a bass, drumsticks and various drums and cymbals, before tossing the items into the fire. The women also throw in amplifiers and Fall Out Boy records such as Take This To Your Grave, From Under the Cork Tree and Live in Phoenix, along with a Fall Out Boy wristband and Fall Out Toy Works comics. 2 Chainz then uses a flamethrower to hasten the incineration process, while the women return to the van and open its rear doors, revealing four hooded, bound men implied to be Fall Out Boy themselves. The camera then closes in on 2 Chainz's face as he holds up a match and stares at the band menacingly, ending the video.[12]

Fall Out Boy's capture is shown in the music video for the following single, "The Phoenix", released on March 25, 2013.

Jon Dolan of Rolling Stone called the song "a big, goofy, stomp-along pop-metal anthem".[13] Jason Lipshutz of Billboard described the song as "a natural evolution of the Fall Out Boy sound," adding also that the song is "muscular in scope and jittery in practice, with rolling chants cresting above Stump's nervous energy."[14] Cassie Whitt of Loudwire called the song a "pop banger".[15] Collin Brennan of Consequence of Sound felt that the song's hip hop-esque beat set "Light Em Up" apart from the band's earlier material.[16]

Commercially, "My Songs Know What You Did in the Dark (Light Em Up)" debuted on charts worldwide with success, reaching in the top five in the United Kingdom, charts the band have previously received success from with singles like "This Ain't a Scene, It's an Arms Race" and "Thnks fr th Mmrs".

On the U.S. Billboard Hot 100, the song debuted at number twenty-six and number eight on the U.S. Billboard Rock Songs chart; it reached number two on iTunes upon its release with 162,000 first week sales. In its nineteenth week on the chart, it reached a peak of number thirteen on the Hot 100 and number two on the Rock Songs chart (upon Save Rock And Roll's release). The song has sold over 5 million downloads in the United States as of August 2015, the first song by Fall Out Boy to reach this level.[17] "My Songs Know What You Did in the Dark" has sold over 600,000 copies in the UK earning a platinum certification by the BPI as of 2023.

• The song, interspersed with All I Do Is Win, is performed acapella by the antagonists of Pitch Perfect 2 at the climax of the movie.
• The song has been known for appearing in several sporting events including the 2013 NBA playoffs player introductions for the Houston Rockets,[18] the Canadian and American television coverage of the 2013 Stanley Cup playoffs, the Pittsburgh Penguins 2013 commercial, intros for NASCAR drivers Aric Almirola and Justin Allgaier at Bristol Motor Speedway,[19][20] the opening night of Monday Night Football during the San Diego Chargers vs. Houston Texans game and the MLB 2013 postseason "We Play October" campaign.[21][22]
• The song was featured in the Xbox One presentation at E3 2013 as part of a montage showing different community creations for the upcoming video game Project Spark.[23]
• "My Song Knows What You Did in the Dark" was featured in the promotional video for the backdoor pilot of The Originals[24] and during the Starz programming lineup.
• The song was featured in the 2013 film Percy Jackson: Sea of Monsters.
• The song was also used during Timber Brown's acrobatic act during the quarter-finals on season 8 of America's Got Talent, the show which Fall Out Boy would later perform the song at with "Alone Together" leading in.[25]
• The song was used for the trailer for Disney's Big Hero 6, a film which featured the band's song "Immortals".[26]
• The song was used for the soundtrack to the video games NHL 15 and Guitar Hero Live, the latter appearing as a playable track.[27][28]
• The song was used during 2022 PDC Challenge Tour winner Scott Williams’ walk ons

A remix, produced by Wonder Arillo, featuring rapper 2 Chainz with hip-hop sound was released on April 3. It was performed live the month before by Fall Out Boy and 2 Chainz at the beginning of the 2013 NBA slam dunk contest.