Gallagher-Kieffer House

The land on which 234 North Dithridge Street now stands was inherited by Isabella W. C. Comingo from her father, Neville B. Craig, who was Pittsburgh's City Solicitor, owner and editor of the Pittsburgh Gazette, and, in 1943, a one-term Representative in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives.[3] Isabella was in the process of partitioning and selling off her land when her last two living children died accidentally. It was said that the deaths of her sons caused her to lose her sanity and, as such, all sales of her property in the preceding eighteen months were reviewed by the courts to confirm that the purchasers had given her a fair price and not taken advantage of Comingo's mental state. When Isabella died on July 23, 1889, her estate was divided between her living siblings. Her sister, Annie Craig Davison, was granted lots six and seven, which is where the Gallagher-Kieffer House stands today.[1]

Annie Davison hired the firm of Bennett & Stitely to build the House in 1893, possibly as a home for her newly married daughter, Mary Davison Reed. When 234 North Dithridge Street was constructed, it was numbered 226 North Dithridge Street. The house number was changed to 234 in 1918, possibly to standardize numbering on that block. Neither Annie nor Mary lived in the House, as the 1990 census shows that they were both living at 4614 Fifth Avenue instead. Annie and Mary died in 1906 and 1908, respectively.[4][1]

The Reverend Henry T. McClelland and his family were the first tenants of the Gallagher-Kieffer House, living there from 1894 until 1904 during McClelland's tenure as pastor of the Bellefield Presbyterian Church. According to the 1900 census, he and his wife, Lizona, had four children, all of whom were attending school. After the McClelland family moved to Washington, PA, the next tenants of the House were the Larkin family, who lived there from 1906 to 1911. The head of the household, Robert Larkin, was a native of Pennsylvania, worked as a clerk, and occupied the House with his four sisters. After the Larkin family moved from the Gallagher-Kieffer House, there are no known records of the tenants who may have lived in the home before it was purchased by the Gallagher family in 1914.[1]

The Gallagher-Kieffer House exemplifies the late-nineteenth century Victorian period Shingle Style of architecture. Its steeply pitched gambrel roof, shingled second floors walls without corner boards, integral porch, and the absence of highly decorative detailing all are characteristic elements of the Shingle style. The House is unique within its Pittsburgh neighborhood, North Oakland, for this architectural style, as many other residential buildings in the area favor Richardsonian Romanesque architecture. The House also features numerous stained glass windows and panes.[1]

• 
  An excerpt from a 1904 plat map showing the Gallagher-Kieffer House between "M.B. Reed" and J.W. Friday.
• 
  The Gallagher-Kieffer House ca. 1920.