Everything Harmony

Professional ratings

Aggregate scores
Source	Rating
Metacritic	88/100[3]
Review scores
Source	Rating
AllMusic	[4]
The Guardian	[5]
The Line of Best Fit	7/10[6]
NME	[1]
PopMatters	8/10[7]
Under the Radar	[8]

Everything Harmony received a score of 88 out of 100 based on eight critics' reviews on review aggregator Metacritic, indicating "universal acclaim".[3] Connor Shelton of The Line of Best Fit stated that the duo "push[ed] themselves toward intriguing new paths" on the album, and while the "first third of the LP shows a band more focused than ever, the lack of playfulness proves a detriment going into the middle chunk" of the album.[6] PopMatters wrote that "their new batch of songs is so derivative of the early to mid-1970s that on first listen to it, it can be hard to hear past the influences", but that the band "echo, and, at times, even improve on those influences with such convincing skill and ebullient spirit that they demand we take them more seriously".[7] Erica Campbell of NME described Everything Harmony as "a melodic and imaginative romp" on which they make "a sound of their own". Campbell added: "when you consider that the album was recorded, produced and engineered solely by the D'Addario brothers, it adds even more weight to the fact that they could create songs that harken back to classics without sounding too derivative".[1]

Reviewing the album for Under the Radar, Ian Rushbury found it to be "not a radical departure from their delightfully rear facing sound" and the duo "have a simpler approach [as] the music they like is reflected in the songs they write, it just happens to be from an era which the cool kids haven't found yet".[8] Ben Beaumont-Thomas of The Guardian opined that the duo "have never mined the past more effectively than on this fourth album", writing that their "biggest touchstone is the beautifully harmonised existential dread of the Beach Boys post-Pet Sounds flop era: rarely has stark despair (one song is called Every Day Is the Worst Day of My Life) sounded so lovely".[5] Fred Thomas of AllMusic felt that the album has the duo "changing directions yet again, turning the volume down and exploring a more sentimental side of their '70s-informed songwriting style", with its "especially gentle songs" like "Any Time of Day" demonstrating "the band's progression the most".[4]

The album appeared at number 78 on the midweek UK Albums Chart dated May 8, 2023.[9]

Credits adapted from Everything Harmony album liner notes.[2]