Entanglement witness

Let a composite quantum system have state space ${\displaystyle H_{A}\otimes H_{B}}$. A mixed state ρ is then a trace-class positive operator on the state space which has trace 1. We can view the family of states as a subset of the real Banach space generated by the Hermitian trace-class operators, with the trace norm. A mixed state ρ is separable if it can be approximated, in the trace norm, by states of the form

${\displaystyle \xi =\sum _{i=1}^{k}p_{i}\,\rho _{i}^{A}\otimes \rho _{i}^{B},}$

where ${\displaystyle \rho _{i}^{A}}$ and ${\displaystyle \rho _{i}^{B}}$ are pure states on the subsystems A and B respectively. So the family of separable states is the closed convex hull of pure product states. We will make use of the following variant of Hahn–Banach theorem:

Theorem Let ${\displaystyle S_{1}}$ and ${\displaystyle S_{2}}$ be disjoint convex closed sets in a real Banach space and one of them is compact, then there exists a bounded functional f separating the two sets.

This is a generalization of the fact that, in real Euclidean space, given a convex set and a point outside, there always exists an affine subspace separating the two. The affine subspace manifests itself as the functional f. In the present context, the family of separable states is a convex set in the space of trace class operators. If ρ is an entangled state (thus lying outside the convex set), then by theorem above, there is a functional f separating ρ from the separable states. It is this functional f, or its identification as an operator, that we call an entanglement witness. There is more than one hyperplane separating a closed convex set from a point lying outside of it, so for an entangled state there is more than one entanglement witness. Recall the fact that the dual space of the Banach space of trace-class operators is isomorphic to the set of bounded operators. Therefore, we can identify f with a Hermitian operator A. Therefore, modulo a few details, we have shown the existence of an entanglement witness given an entangled state:

Theorem For every entangled state ρ, there exists a Hermitian operator A such that ${\displaystyle \operatorname {Tr} (A\,\rho )<0}$, and ${\displaystyle \operatorname {Tr} (A\,\sigma )\geq 0}$ for all separable states σ.

When both ${\displaystyle H_{A}}$ and ${\displaystyle H_{B}}$ have finite dimension, there is no difference between trace-class and Hilbert–Schmidt operators. So in that case A can be given by Riesz representation theorem. As an immediate corollary, we have:

Theorem A mixed state σ is separable if and only if

${\displaystyle \operatorname {Tr} (A\,\sigma )\geq 0}$

for any bounded operator A satisfying ${\displaystyle \operatorname {Tr} (A\cdot P\otimes Q)\geq 0}$, for all product pure state ${\displaystyle P\otimes Q}$.

If a state is separable, clearly the desired implication from the theorem must hold. On the other hand, given an entangled state, one of its entanglement witnesses will violate the given condition.

Thus if a bounded functional f of the trace-class Banach space and f is positive on the product pure states, then f, or its identification as a Hermitian operator, is an entanglement witness. Such a f indicates the entanglement of some state.

Using the isomorphism between entanglement witnesses and non-completely positive maps, it was shown (by the Horodeckis) that

Theorem Assume that ${\displaystyle H_{A},H_{B}}$ are finite-dimensional. A mixed state ${\displaystyle \sigma \in L(H_{A})\otimes L(H_{B})}$ is separable if for every positive map Λ from bounded operators on ${\displaystyle H_{B}}$ to bounded operators on ${\displaystyle H_{A}}$, the operator ${\displaystyle (I_{A}\otimes \Lambda )(\sigma )}$ is positive, where ${\displaystyle I_{A}}$ is the identity map on ${\displaystyle \;L(H_{A})}$, the bounded operators on ${\displaystyle H_{A}}$.

• Terhal, Barbara M. (2000). "Bell inequalities and the separability criterion". Physics Letters A. 271 (5–6): 319–326. arXiv:quant-ph/9911057. Bibcode:2000PhLA..271..319T. doi:10.1016/S0375-9601(00)00401-1. ISSN 0375-9601. Also available at quant-ph/9911057
• R.B. Holmes. Geometric Functional Analysis and Its Applications, Springer-Verlag, 1975.
• M. Horodecki, P. Horodecki, R. Horodecki, Separability of Mixed States: Necessary and Sufficient Conditions, Physics Letters A 223, 1 (1996) and arXiv:quant-ph/9605038
• Z. Ficek, "Quantum Entanglement Processing with Atoms", Appl. Math. Inf. Sci. 3, 375–393 (2009).
• Barry C. Sanders and Jeong San Kim, "Monogamy and polygamy of entanglement in multipartite quantum systems", Appl. Math. Inf. Sci. 4, 281–288 (2010).
• Gühne, O.; Tóth, G. (2009). "Entanglement detection". Phys. Rep. 474 (1–6): 1–75. arXiv:0811.2803. Bibcode:2009PhR...474....1G. doi:10.1016/j.physrep.2009.02.004.