Dorothy (opera)

Cellier, Leslie and Stephenson

Although billed as a "comic opera" like the popular Gilbert and Sullivan operas on the London stage at the same time, Dorothy was a key forerunner of the Edwardian musical comedy, bearing many of the attributes of that genre. Its libretto is more farcical than W. S. Gilbert's satiric libretti, revolving around mistaken identities and topical humour instead of topsy-turvy plot absurdities. Dorothy anticipated George Edwardes's musical comedy hits of the 1890s and 1900s, and its remarkable success showed Edwardes and other theatre managers that audiences were ready for a shift towards the more topical pieces that soon dominated the musical theatre stage.

In 1885, Cellier had composed a song, "There once was a time, my darling", for a piece produced by Edwardes, Little Jack Sheppard (1885). Cellier, who had been a lieutenant of Arthur Sullivan, re-purposed much of the music for Dorothy from his unsuccessful comic opera of ten years earlier, Nell Gwynne, the music of which had been praised.[2] Stephenson wrote new lyrics and a libretto to fit the music. He wrote a well-crafted play, with literary echoes of familiar themes reminiscent of Jane Austen's Emma, yet with a more modern style, suggesting its eighteenth-century setting lightly rather than with the archaic literary tone common in Victorian drama. The work was mounted in London in the absence of Cellier, who was then in Australia conducting Gilbert and Sullivan operas. In his absence it became clear that the opera needed a big romantic ballad, and Cellier's publisher Chappell suggested using one of his existing songs, "Old Dreams", which with new words as "Queen of my Heart" was interpolated into the piece and became a huge success. The sheet music sold over 40,000 copies, and the popularity of the song saved the opera from failure.[3][4]

The piece opened at the Gaiety Theatre on 25 September 1886. It starred Marion Hood in the title role opposite the popular Hayden Coffin, with comedians Arthur Williams, Furneaux Cook and John Le Hay.[5] This was the first production at the Gaiety by new managing director (and later owner) of the theatre, George Edwardes, who misjudged his audience. The Gaiety was then known for burlesque, and its audiences were not looking for Gilbert and Sullivan style comic opera. The piece received lukewarm notices, and neither the music nor the libretto attracted critical praise. The Times wrote, "Gentility reigns supreme, and with it unfortunately also a good deal of the refined feebleness and the ineptitude which are the defects of that quality."[6] After a few months, Edwardes sold the production to his accountant, Henry J. Leslie.

Furneaux Cook as Squire Bantam

Stephenson and Cellier revised the show, and Leslie added new stars, including Ben Davies and Marie Tempest, who took over the title role from the ailing Hood and became one of musical theatre's biggest stars.[7] The piece reopened at the Prince of Wales's Theatre on 20 December 1886 and transferred to the Lyric Theatre on 17 December 1888, where it closed on 6 April 1889. Florence Perry made her London stage debut in 1887 in the role of Phyllis Tuppitt.[5]

The revised Dorothy became a great success at the box office and had an initial run of 931 performances, breaking the record for the longest-running musical theatre production in history and holding this record until the run of the musical play A Chinese Honeymoon in the early 1900s.[8] It was also the second longest known run for a stage production of any kind, after Our Boys, an 1875 vaudeville play, until both were surpassed by the run of Charley's Aunt in the 1890s.[8] The show's hit songs included the ballad "Queen of My Heart", "Be Wise In Time", "Hark For'ard!", "With A Welcome To All", and "The Time Has Come." Henry Leslie made so much money from Dorothy that he was able to build the Lyric Theatre, where the show transferred in 1888. The success of the show also spurred revivals of some of Cellier's earlier works.[9] Some critics reconsidered their earlier condemnation, the work became regarded as a classic Victorian piece,[4] and the initially despised plot was traced seriously back to the Restoration playwrights David Garrick and Aphra Behn, and to Oliver Goldsmith and even Shakespeare.[10]

Arthur Williams as William Lurcher, from The Sketch, 1894

Dorothy also toured and enjoyed numerous revivals in Britain until at least 1908,[4] with four or five separate and simultaneous companies during the early years. Decima Moore played the title role in the 1892 revival. Courtice Pounds played Wilder on a 1900 provincial tour.[5] There was also a New York run from 5 November 1887 to April 1888 starring Lillian Russell as the title character, and the show was revived in America until about 1900. A successful tour of Australia also began in 1887, with Leonora Braham making her Australian debut,[11] followed by an 1888 production starring Nellie Stewart and more revivals into the 1890s.[12] John D'Auban choreographed a West End revival in 1892 at the Trafalgar Square Theatre.[13]

The story of Dorothy reflects touches of cynicism, early feminism, and utilises plenty of mistaken-identity and social-class-distinction comic situations. Elements of the story are derived from the 1847 opera Martha by Friedrich von Flotow,[14] a tale of two wealthy young ladies who dress as peasants to go to the fair, fall in love with two young farmers and, after exploits, identity-confusion and ring-exchanges, are reunited with them.

• Sir John Bantam, "The Squire" of Chanticleer Hall (baritone) – Furneaux Cook
• Geoffrey Wilder, Sir John Bantam's nephew and heir, a London Gallant (tenor) – Redfern Hollins; replaced by Ben Davies
• Harry Sherwood, Geoffrey Wilder's friend (baritone) – C. Hayden Coffin
• John Tuppitt, Landlord of the "Hop-Pole Inn" – Edward Griffin
• William Lurcher, A Sheriff's Officer (comic baritone) – Arthur Williams
• Tom Strutt (or Tom Grass), A Young Farmer – John Le Hay
• Dorothy Bantam, Sir John Bantam's Daughter (soprano) – Marion Hood; replaced for by Marie Tempest; Hood returned in 1887.[15]
• Lydia Hawthorne, Her Cousin (mezzo-soprano) – Florence Dysart; replaced by Edith Chester and also Amy Augarde
• Phyllis Tuppitt, The Landlord's Daughter, in love with Tom Strutt (contralto) – F. Lambeth; replaced by Grace Huntly and then by Florence Perry
• Lady Betty, A Spinster – Jennie McNulty; replaced by Florence Neville
• Mrs. Privett, A Widow (non-singing) – Harriet Coveney
• Chorus of Hop-Pickers, Peasants, Guests, Bridesmaids, etc.

Tempest in the title role

Davies as Geoffrey Wilder

Act I

• 1. Opening Chorus and Ballet – "Lads and lasses round about the hop-pole trip"
• 2. Song with Trio – "Be wise in time, Oh Phyllis mine" (Dorothy, Lydia, and Phyllis)
• 3. Quartet – "We're sorry to delay you" (Dorothy, Lydia, Wilder, and Sherwood)
• 4. Ballad – "With such a dainty dame none can compare" (Wilder)
• 5 Quintet – "A father's pride and joy they are" (Dorothy, Lydia, Wilder, Sherwood, and Tuppitt)
• 6. Song and Trio – "I am the Sheriff's faithful man" (Lurcher, Wilder, and Sherwood)
• 7. Quartet – "You swear to be good and true" (Dorothy, Lydia, Wilder, and Sherwood)
• 8. Chorus with Solo – "Under the pump" (Lurcher)
• 9. Act I Finale – "Now take your seats at table spread"

Act II

• 10. Act II Introduction and Country Dance
• 11. Song – "Though born a man of high degree" (Wilder and Chorus)
• 12. Music for the Entrance of Dorothy and Lydia
• 13. Graceful Dance
• 14. Song – "Contentment I give you and all that it brings" (Bantam)
• 15. Septet and Chorus – "Now let's to bed" (Dorothy, Lydia, Wilder, Sherwood, Lurcher, and Bantam)
• 16. Recit and Quartett – "One moment pray" (Dorothy, Lydia, Wilder, and Sherwood)
• 16a. Ballad – "I stand at your threshold sighing" ("Queen of my Heart") (Sherwood)
• 17. Trio – "Are you sure that they are all in bed?" (Wilder, Sherwood, and Bantam)
• 18. Chorus with Dorothy, Lydia, Wilder, Sherwood, Bantam, and Lurcher – "What noise was that"
• 19. Act II Finale – "Hark forward"

Act III

• 20. Act III – Ballet
• 21. Chorus – "Dancing is not what it used to be"
• 22. Ballad – "The time has come when I must yield" (Phyllis)
• 23. Septet and Chorus – "What joy untold to feel at last"
• 24. Act III Finale – "You swore to be good and true"

No. 16a became a successful ballad standard, "Queen of My Heart."

Decima Moore as Dorothy, 1892–93 revival

The press praised the music and the original production but had mixed reactions to the performances; they disliked the libretto. The Pall Mall Gazette said, "The story is curiously devoid of any interest, the dialogue is of the weakest, the lyrics have no point.... Mr Cellier's music is worthy a better fate."[16] Other papers agreed: "To put it plainly, the libretto is not worthy of the music."[17] Punch wrote, "The music is much better than the plot – not that this is saying much.... I fancy that Herr Meyer Lutz must have received instructions not to indulge in any of his old frivolous ways, but to conduct the music gravely and sedately – which he did. I was wondering whether he was awake all the time."[18] Many of the critics complained that the libretto was derivative, primarily of She Stoops to Conquer.[17][6]

Bernard Shaw, seeing the piece well into its long run, wrote of his pity for the cast: "Here are several young persons doomed to spend the flower of their years in mechanically repeating the silliest libretto in modern theatrical literature, set to music which, pretty as it is, must pall somewhat on the seven hundred and eighty-eighth performance.... I did not wait for the third act. My companion had all but fallen into the pit from sleep and heaviness of spirit combined.... It is a criminal waste of young lives and young talents."[19] The Times wrote:

Not a trace of the loudness and vulgarity of the old Gaiety burlesque remains. Gentility reigns supreme, and with it unfortunately also a good deal of the refined feebleness and the ineptitude which are the defects of that quality. Neither Mr. Stephenson nor Mr. Cellier has quite met the requirements of the occasion. The former has provided a disjointed and uninteresting book and the latter a score which, although elegant, varied, and full of colour, consists almost entirely of concerted pieces, notwithstanding that there are some excellent singers in the cast.... As a desperate expedient in construction we have seen few situations to equal that at the close of the second act of Dorothy. The inmates of Chanticleer-hall (among whom the female element appears to be in an immense preponderance) are aroused from their slumbers in the middle of the night, and troop upon the stage in their night dresses. A climax to this scene, however, is needed, and Mr. Stephenson finds it in the advent of a troop of scarlet clad huntsmen, with whom the ladies, forgetful of their attire, go off to the chase—an incident that supplies the composer with opportunity for a fine hunting chorus. The music is throughout by far the best feature of the piece. Miss Marion Hood plays with much sprightliness and considerable vocal ability the part of Dorothy, and is well supported by Miss Florence Dysart as Lydia. Mr. Redfern Rollins, who has a voice but no acting capacity, is young Wilder, and Mr. Hayden Coffin, who can both sing and act, but who unfortunately is not provided with a single song, is Sherwood. In other respects the rest is as good as need be.[6]

By the time of a 1908 revival, The Times had a more favourable view: "It is twenty-one years since Dorothy was produced.... Clearly, it is impossible to bring a cool mind to bear in judgment on Dorothy. It belongs to the golden past; it is enshrined in memory; to hear it is to grow young again. To analyse it or criticize it would be to question the beauty of the ladies with whom we were then in love.... And the pleasantest feeling of all is the conviction that Dorothy completely deserves the admiration we lavished on it. It is one of the most tuneful, most charming, and most shapely of English comic operas."[4]

In 2019, Victorian Opera Northwest released the first professional recording of the piece, conducted by Richard Bonynge with Majella Cullagh, Lucy Vallis, Stephanie Maitland, Matt Mears and the Royal Northern College of Music.[20]

• Herbert, Ian, ed. (1972). Who's Who in the Theatre (fifteenth ed.). London: Sir Isaac Pitman and Sons. ISBN 978-0-273-31528-5.

Another photo of Williams as Lurcher

• Walters, Michael. "Dorothy Sketches". The Gaiety (Autumn 2005). (pp. 35–36)
• Midkiff, Neil. "Discovering Dorothy". The Gaiety (Autumn 2005). (pp. 38–42)
• Kenig, Marc. "Dorothy's Degrees of Separation". The Gaiety (Autumn 2005). (pp. 43–44)
• Dorothy at The Gilbert & Sullivan Archive
• Midkiff, Neil. "Discovering Dorothy"

• Links to synopsis, downloadable vocal score, midi files, cast lists and other info.
• Dorothy at The Guide to Light Opera and Operetta
• Long Runs in Theatre, a list of records listing the longest runs ever achieved by stage productions of any type
• Gillan, Don. Longest Running Plays in London and New York, 1875 to 1920 at the Stage Beauty website (2007)
• IBDB entry for the first production in New York
• Photo of the score of Dorothy
• Theatre poster from performances at Royal Lyceum Theatre, Edinburgh in 1887